Doreen, You've got me well and truly confused. 1861 has her transcribed as Anet, but I'd look at the original image. Buying the 1867 marriage certificate of Harriet Saxton & George Ball, should prove her father. The second problem seems to be an error in the relationship to Henry Broomhead in 1881 census. He'd only be 12 when Harriet was born, so too young for her father. I'd suggest you trace him in 1841, 1851, 1861 and 1871. He could be a relative of some kind. Peter