Robin, I notice that on both FreeBMD site and Newcastle Register Office site, Carlisle-born Constance Edith's marraige is registered as Edith. Also on 1901 census ( 4777-96-7) both her and her Felton-born brother Charles are recorded as Newcastle-born. So.... a candidate for Constance Edith on 1891 census.... In Westgate area of Newcastle (like Benwell on west side of Newcastle) there is a 16 yr old Edith, servant, but recorded as born North Shields (4191-49-26) ? Michael Dixon