I am searching for proof of parentage of Phebe Lindsley of New Vernon who married Timothy Lindsley (Lindley) about 1742, around the time 1st Presbyterian Church of Morristown was established. Their marriage doesn't seem to be recorded there. Circumstantial evidence indicates she was the daughter of John Lindsley & Sarah Plum. However, other sources say that Phebe Lindsley m. Jacob Cooke (Cook)of Mendham. I suspect that Mrs. Cooke is a descendant of Joseph Lindsley rather than John. Does anyone have proof of Mrs. Mills' ancestry, or know the location of early New Vernon records? Thank you very much. Caroline Regards, Caroline Have you checked out www.awindowsouth.com ?