I was just looking more closely at this and I can eliminate one of the below - 3) John Cleveland and Ethel (Harris) Dougherty are in my family line and they had 2 sons, John Martin, b 9 Jul 1913, d 13 Jan 1987, and William Paul, b 4 Sep 1920, still living. Helen Kathy, I am sorry, no help here I am afraid. I found 1) Arthur Dougherty, born aft 1870 and died aft 1920, son of John David and Ellen (Durnell) Dougherty. Depending on exact ages it is possible. 2) Arthur Dougherty, born 23 Aug 1894 and died 10 May 1973, husband of Mary Elizabeth Ridgeway. I have only daughters for this couple - Martha Belle born 6 Oct 1921 and Mae Louella born 9 May 1934. These ages are not good. 3) Arthur Dougherty, son of John Cleveland (born 9 Nov 1884) and Ethel (Harris) Dougherty. Once again the age is not good. 4) Claude F., son of Paris and Annie E. (Patton) Dougherty, born 13 Nov 1881. Like you say the ages are not good. Oh well, maybe someone will come up with something. Cecil V. Boyd