I just located my pages from the Cass Twp. 1880 Census, and it looks like Thomas and Elizabeth's 2nd child could have been an "Arsulie." I can't quite make it out, but she would have been born in 1877. the first daughter was Cynthia A., who was 6, then Arsulie, 3, and Samantha 1. I've been searching for who she belonged to for some time. She was born Sep 14,1877; d. July 9, 1907. (Dau. of B. & E. Hutchison)