Ah not so Eileen, I think genealogy puzzles like this would make anyone flip. lol Plus posting all of our conversations corresponding to the subject matter might jog someone's memory. Mine could use a lot of jogging, ha. You know it could be that Huldah could have married a Dibble in New York and had no children, divorced or her husband died. Then later married AUSTIN brothers, one being Fred in New York. Maybe one died and the other AUSTIN she married in Michigan. Like maybe Fred first then Jeremiah. That's how the first two children's last name could have stayed AUSTIN. Them after her husband died she married an Olmsted and had no other children. What do you think of that? Can't wait till your next trip, or better yet if you can talk to the g granddaughter of Huldahs. Take care and have a safe holiday God Bless Pam