For Bill in Montana Re WEST CHARLTON; and variants; the 1881 British Census CD do not show up this place name, but Calton gets many "hits" both Edinburgh and Lanarks areas. You may wish to consider CALTON Edinburgh complete with prison; Edinburgh High School; burial ground/s observatory,etc as a place to examine.Old Ordnance Survey Maps Edinburgh Calton Hill 1852-1877 Edinburgh Sheet 30 published by Alan Godfrey Maps gives much more detail of CALTON. John in downtown Aus