Hi Pam, >From the 1851 census, it is clear that your David Rodger was born in Inveresk. Furthermore, from the 1841 census, it is clear that the St. Cuthbert's born DR is somebody else. Best wishes, Sheena -----Original Message----- From: "pam.groves1" <[email protected]> The only two David Roger born about 1805 are a David Roger Christened in Inveresk on 23 June 1805 with the parents named John Roger and Agnes Kirkwood or a David Rodger Christened 25 December 1807 in Saint Cuthberts, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland with the Parents named James Rodger and Margaret Telfard.