Hi again, Looking on familysearch.com, I see a David McCormick in the Michigan census in Alpena, living in the household of a John Garigan. Info states that this David was born in 1856 in Ontario. Alpena is just straight across from Charlevoix/Beaver Island...I know the age is off by about 7 years, but that is not uncommon in census info. Just a possibility anyway...will go look there some more. Kathy