Hi Joe -- I may have some information for you on your William Reynolds. If he is the one I think he is, he was a very significant player in the Lutheran Church in PA and OH during the mid-1800s. He was the first President of Capital University, a Lutheran school in Columbus, OH. He died 5 Sept 1876 in Oak Park, IL. Contact me privately if this is the right guy. I have quite a bit about him, including a photo. Susan Kundert Coshocton, OH