Mary Yoder, I don't know who all these Charles Medcalf's are you list below. What I do know is the will I posted was that of Charles Medcalf who married Elizabeth JUPIN. Once you add all his children into your data base as I posted a few days ago you will have many of the Medcalf's you can't seem to figure out as to who the parents were, and it won't be a question as to which Charles Medcalf, because the one I'm talking about married Elizabeth JUPIN Eleanor Medcalf who married John SMITH is a daughter of Charles MEDCALF and Elizabeth JUPIN. He verifies that in his will. I posted all of those Children and their marriages of Charles Medcalf and Elizabeth JUPIN just the other day. Use that with his will and you should be able to put together their family. I don't know who the Charles Medcalf of Shelby County, KY is. Charles Medcalf who married Elizabeth JUPIN was in Nelson County, Ky until he died in Spencer County, KY -----Original Message----- From: mdstmary-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:mdstmary-bounces@rootsweb.com] On Behalf Of mary.yoder@verizon.net Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2009 6:07 PM To: MDSTMARY@rootsweb.c Subject: Re: [MDSTMARY] Charles Metcalf & Elizabeth Jupin Which Charles Metcalf are you talking about??? 1810 Bardstown, Nelson Co, Ky John K. Metcalf 22101 - 01001-00 1820 Ky Index-- Charles Metcalf only: Charles Metcalf Bardstown, Nelson, KY; p 180 100101 - 038? 1- 05 & slaves Charles Metcalf Bardstown, Nelson, Ky; p 37/211? 2001?? - 03201 04 & slaves Charles Metcalf, Shelby Co, KY; p 130A, 131 000001 - 00001 - 02 2 slaves 1830 Ky Index- Charles Metcalf Only: Charles Metcalfe, Nelson Co, Ky; p 156: 0001000100000 - 0001100100000 1840 Ky Index--Charles Metcalf Only Chas Metcalf-Taylorville, Simpson, KY 1810 Ky Index--Charles MEDCALF only Charles Medcalf--Bardstown, Nelson, Ky; p 366 01010 - 12010 - 04 (John K. MEDCALF Bardstown, Nelson Co; p 14/188? (110201 - 00??1 03 no slaves) (John MEDCALF 100020 - ???10 01 no slaves (not together on page). 1840 KY Cen Index- Charles MEDCALF Charles MEDCALF-Hardin Co, KY; p 33 0000011000000 - 1100110000000 Very true--the Nelson Co mg has d/o of Charles but WHICH CHARLES??? That is why I hesitate to place any children with any of the Charles!!! Mary Y. ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to MDSTMARY-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message