I couldn't find fault with the Old Scottish Parish records. It's been a while since I used them to find Willisons. If I recall correctly, what you got to see was pictures of the parish records. Having spent a lot of time recently transcribing some old church records, I can see where a lot of mistakes could be made. Not all pastors could write well so I've been trying to figure out what is written by using a lot of research material. Usually that doesn't help either. Old books can become damaged in time if not cared for properly. Connie