This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/rw/FG0.2ACIB/1082.3 Message Board Post: Sorry, I don't usually send multiple replies, but I kept on researching your information and came up with a theory on Duncan. Duncan died 1850. John R Eaton was born 1847. He would have only been about three years old when Duncan died. If Sally remarried, John may have simply kept her maiden name. Then I found this: Name: Sarah (Sally) EATON Sex: F Birth: 1825 in Whitley County, Kentucky 1 Note: Sources: Grubb.GED Ernie Grubb May 2000 Peggy Hinshaw, 519 Meadowlark Lane, Newton, KS 67114 Father: Benjamin EATON b: 27 Feb 1793 in North Carolina Mother: Sarah Sally GRUBB b: 24 Jul 1799 Marriage 1 David JONES Married: 15 Sep 1850 in Whitley County, Kentucky 2 Note the marriage late in the year that Duncan died.