Dale, I'm not aware of another article on the MF 3 Soule book and I think it's unlikely. Neil Thompson did quite a good job critiquing the first 3 volumes of the 5 generations books and left very little unsaid! I'm off this very minute for a few days rest at the cottage but when I get back I can look into it. I have an article in the next issue of TAG and can ask David Greene (Editor) if he knows of any such article such as the one you suggest. Susan. www.rootsweb.com/~canms/canada.html ----- Original Message ----- From: "Dale H Cook" <radiotest@juno.com> To: <MAYFLOWER-L@rootsweb.com> Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2002 1:06 PM Subject: Re: Fw: [MFLR] Jonathan4 Soule > On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 12:50:32 -0400 "Susan E. Roser" <roser@iprimus.ca> > writes: > > > TG 1 [1980]: 229, ["Mayflower Families To Date: A > > Critical Examination", by Neil D. Thompson, F.A.S.G.] - in response > > to the Soule, vol. 3, MF silver book published in 1980 ... > > Susan - > > It is very good to see you back. > > Perhaps you can answer a queation I posed to Jim. In addition to the > Thompson article you cited, was there not another critical article > comcerning MF5G v. 3 Soule, perhaps by Wakefield, published perhaps in > TAG? I recall reading one, and I don't have local access to TG so I'm > sure it wasn't the Thompson article. > > Dale H. Cook, Chief Engineer, WWWR Roanoke VA, WCQV Moneta VA, WKBA WZZI > Vinton VA, WKPA WLNI WLVA WZZU Lynchburg VA > > ______________________________