Dale asked me a few days ago if I knew of any other article, likely printed in TAG (The American Genealogist) which did a review of the MF books, in particular, the Soule MF, vol. 3. I was aware of only the following: TG 1 [1980]: 229, ["Mayflower Families To Date: A Critical Examination", by Neil D. Thompson, F.A.S.G.] . I have checked with the Editor of TAG and Dale was correct, there was indeed another article which was written by George McCracken in TAG [1981]: 57-58. I have not read the article so do not know its contents. Susan E. Roser www.rootsweb.com/~canms/canada.html