This may be your guy in 1860 census. Name:Chas S Tarbell Age in 1860:12 Birth Year:abt 1848 Birthplace:Massachusetts Home in 1860:Brimfield, Hampden, Massachusetts Gender:Male Post Office:Palmer Value of real estate: Household Members:NameAge N F Tarbell39 Mary A Tarbell35 Chas S Tarbell12 Mary A Tarbell3 Alice Tarbell73