William, I can follow all you are saying below but I don't have the marriage of an Austin Mattingly to Ann Elizabeth Bartlett. But I do show Augustine D Mattingly as the son of George Austin "Big George" Mattingly. I don't show a son Austin. Gerald Thompson in his "KY Catholic Pioneers" states that Augustine b. abt 1828 was the son of George Austin Mattingly and Ann "Nancy" Johnson per Holy Naame of Mary Catholic Church baptismal records where Augustine is listed as baptized on 10/28/1828. Godparents were Henry and Catherine (Flanagan) Johnson. Also George Austin and Nancy Mattingly are listed among those buried in the St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery in Daviess Co, KY. George is listed as George E which looks like an error and was b. 10/30/1802 d. 10/31/1883. Nancy is listed as b. 12/15/1807 d. 10/23/1869, wife of George. A couple of years ago I was at the Filson Club in Louisville and in the backroom files are a series of folders with information by Father Lyons. One of these folders is titled the Calvary Genealogy. It has family data by surname. I copied a few pages, on Mattingly, Carrico, Bickett and a few others. Would like to copy the entire file someday. But there is a page titled "George Mattingly, son of Basil Mattingly of Leonard . States that George married Anna Johnson or Johnston on 1/22/1828, HNMCC, Calvary, KY. Says that Geoge and Nancy raised 8 children and moved to Daviess Co, KY. George died in 1885 (there are a few differences such as George's deathdate of 1885 vs 1883 per St Lawrence records and the fact that in 1850 the parish census of St Mary of the Woods, Whitesville lists Geroge with 12 in the household including 10 children. Think a couple were not found in the baptismal registers. But these were listed. Augustine and Amanda were bap on Calvary, KY, the rest st St Lawrence in DAviess Co, KY. Augustine D bap 12/28/1828; Amanda Catherine b. 4/10/1830, bap 5/30/1820; Harriet b. 7/1/1834 bap 8/10/1834; Eleanor b. 8/12/1836 bap 9/25/1836; George Milton b. 1/11/1835 bap 4/23/1835; Eliza Jane b. 2/9/1840 bap 5/17/1840; Mary Ann b. 5/3/1941 bap 8/15/1841; Patrick Johnson b. (not listed) bap 2/15/1847; Rosette b. 1/20/1849 bap 5/13/1849. Per census records I find a John b. abt 1832 and a Nancy b. abt 1844. Below is a couple of generations of George Austin Mattingly as I show it. Bob Alvey Descendants of George Austin "Big George" Mattingly 1 George Austin "Big George" Mattingly b: October 30, 1802 in Prob Washington Co, KY d: October 31, 1883 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY .+Ann "Nancy" Johnson b: December 15, 1807 in KY m: January 22, 1828 in Washington Co, KY d: December 23, 1869 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY Father: Henry Johnson Mother: Catherine Flanagan ..2 Augustine D Mattingly b: Bef. October 29, 1828 in Washington Co, KY ...... +Catherine Johnson m: 1846 in Prob Daviess Co, KY ..2 Amanda Catherine Mattingly b: April 10, 1830 in Washington Co, KY d: April 12, 1912 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY ...... +Thomas Monarch b: October 16, 1817 in KY m: October 23, 1848 in Daviess Co, KY d: March 10, 1864 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY Father: James Monarch, Sr Mother: Ruth Russell ....... 3 Georgia Anna Monarch b: August 29, 1849 in Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Mary Rosetta Monarch b: January 14, 1852 in Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Baby Monarch b: October 10, 1854 in Daviess Co, KY d: October 10, 1854 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Alice M Monarch b: February 02, 1858 in Daviess Co, KY d: March 08, 1861 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Ellen Generose Monarch b: March 08, 1861 in Daviess Co, KY ........... +Aloysius Militisus Howard b: February 12, 1855 in KY m: Abt. 1879 Father: Aloysius Howard Mother: Martha Anne Shanks ....... 3 Harriett Lee "Hattie" Monarch b: September 05, 1863 in Daviess Co, KY ........... +John Calvin Simmons ..2 John Mattingly b: 1832 in KY ..2 Harriett Mattingly b: July 01, 1834 in Daviess Co, KY d: February 26, 1884 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY ..2 George Milton Mattingly b: June 11, 1835 in Daviess Co, KY ..2 Eleanor Mattingly b: August 12, 1836 in Daviess Co, KY ..2 Elizabeth Jane Mattingly b: February 09, 1840 in Daviess Co, KY d: February 17, 1931 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: Mater Dolorosa Catholic Cemetery, Daviess co, KY ...... +Thomas J Monarch, Sr b: April 26, 1836 in Owensboro, Daviess Co, KY m: July 10, 1865 in Daviess Co, KY d: July 21, 1887 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: Mater Dolorosa Catholic Cemetery, Daviess co, KY Father: Thomas Monarch Mother: Susan Davis ....... 3 Henrietta "Etta" Monarch b: August 20, 1866 in Daviess Co, KY d: September 26, 1940 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: Mater Dolorosa Catholic Cemetery, Daviess co, KY ........... +Edwin P Millett b: May 20, 1856 in Vincesses, IN d: January 14, 1941 in Daviess Co, KY Burial: Mater Dolorosa Catholic Cemetery, Daviess co, KY ....... 3 Consuela Monarch b: 1869 in Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Susan Monarch b: 1872 in Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Paul Monarch b: 1877 in Daviess Co, KY ....... 3 Thomas J Monarch, Jr b: 1879 in Daviess Co, KY ..2 Mary Ann Mattingly b: March 03, 1841 in Daviess Co, KY ..2 Ann "Nancy" Mattingly b: 1844 in Daviess Co, KY ..2 Patrick Johnson Mattingly b: Abt. February 15, 1847 in Daviess Co, KY ..2 Rosette Mattingly b: January 20, 1849 in Davess Co, KY d: January 28, 1850 in Davess Co, KY Burial: St Lawrence Catholic Cemetery, Daviess Co, KY > Ralph and all, I have this George as having married Ann Nancy Johnson. I > currently carry him as George Austin and being in Daviess Co., Ky. during > the 1850 census but dying in Daviess County, Indiana. This is the one whose > nickname was reported as being "Big George". I know some researchers carry > two men, one George and one Austin but I think they're the same man. I have > some difficulties with the off-spring of George. I believe he only had the > one son named Augustine but he must have went by Austin also (appears that > way on some records). I currently carry both men as sons of George but only > so I can try to delete one of the wives. For instance, I show Augustine as > marrying a Catherine Johnson and Austin as marrying Ann Elizabeth Bartlett. > The same man likely married both women but I haven't been able to verify > that yet. > > ****************** > I have a George Mattingly, b. 1803, Washington County, Kentucky; d. > 1885, Daviess County, Kentucky; son of Basil (1772-1835), son of Leonard > (1739-1829). Is this any kind of a clue? > >