In the 1870 census of Daviess Co. IN Barr Twp. I find: Mattingley, Catherine f 39 KY Frances L f 19 KY Henrietta f 17 KY Juliann f 15 KY Gonsey D. m 10 KY Mary J. f 8 KY With the information from the baptisms I am sure this is Catherine (Herbert) Mattingly. I see a Gonza Mattingly age 20 in the household of James Herbert and Melinda in Daviess Co. IN in 1880.