Well wrong again , I just rechecked and I have John Oswald date wrong It looks like to me at this point it may be John Reece but the 1860 Marion Co census proves different. 1850 Daviess Co. Census Mattingly George 47 M Mattingly Nancy 43 F Mattingly Austin 21 M Mattingly John 18 M Mattingly Harriet 16 F Mattingly Ellen 14 F Mattingly Milton 12 M Mattingly Eliza J. 10 F Mattingly Mary A. 8 F Mattingly Nancy 6 F Mattingly Patrick 3 M Find these, you will see sometimes it says George Austin John Mattingly (M) Birth: 1832 -- Death: WFT Est. 1833-1922 -- Parents: George Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnson Milton Mattingly (M) Birth:1838- Death: WFT Est. 1839-1928 Parents: George Austin Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnston Ellen Mattingly (F) Birth: 1836 -- Death: WFT Est. 1837-1930 -- Parents: George Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnson Nancy Mattingly (F) Birth: 1844 -- Death:WFT Est. 1845-1938 Parents: George Austin Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnson Elizabeth J. Mattingly (F) Birth: ABT. 1841 -- Parents: George Austin Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnston Patrick Mattingly (M) Birth: 1847 -- Death: WFT Est. 1848-1937 -- Parents: George Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnson On one occasion I found this which is wrong ? John Reece Mattingly (M) Birth: 1832 -- Marion County, Kentucky Death: 31 JUL 1894 -- Marion County, Kentucky Spouse: , Elizabeth Rhodes Parents: George Austin Mattingly, Ann Nancy Johnson Anyway , anyone have any thoughts on this or ideas for me to check on? Donna [email protected]