Linda & William, I believe that Linda meant the 1870 Washington Co, KY census. In that census James Mattingly age 45 is listed with his wife Elizabeth (she is listed as only 22? too young to be the Elizabeth Kenndey he married in 1855), Samuel age 14, Naomi age 13, Mary age 9, Elizabeth age 4 and George age 1. This James Mattingly seems to be the same as the one listed in the 1850 census with his mother Priscilla (she is listed as age 74, can she really be the mother to these children?) and also the same James who first married Servilla Keeling, daughter of Willaim Keeling and Ann "Nancy" Hardin. Delilah and Elizabeth "Lizzie" below were also daughters of William and Ann Keeling. Three doors away is John Mattingly (John Thomas) age 41, his wife Lizzie age 29 (this age seems wrong also if she is the Elizabeth Keeling he married also in 1855), William age 17, John age 15, Mary age 14, George age 12, Susan age 9, Thomas age 7, Martha age 1 and Miltie age 5. This looks like John Thomas Mattingly brother to James and son of Bernard Mattingly and Priscilla Cash. He first married Delilah M Keeling and William and John would be her children. I cannot prove without question that James in the 1870 Washington co, KY census is the son of Barnard Mattingly and Priscilla Cash but it certainly looks that way. even from earlier census records and the Washington Co, KY marriage records. There is a listing in the 1850 Washington Co, KY census for Priscilla Mattingly age 74 b. KY?? with the following members of her household; Lucretica age 38, John age 28, Caleb age 25, James age 23, Susan M age 8 and Sarah J age 3. I have thought this to be Priscilla Cash widow of Bernard Mattingly (parents unknown) 4/25/1808 in Washington Co, KY per marriage records. If this is so, then this James might be the same one who was 45 in the 1870 census. I cannot find any of them in the 1860 Washington Co, KY census. The only one of this bunch I can find in the 1860 Washington Co, KY census is W C Mattingly (William Caleb) age 36, son of Bernard Mattingly and Priscilla Cash and brother to James and John above. He married Mary Jane Hardesty in 1852. A lot more work need here so any additions or corrections welcome. I know almost nothing of the Lewis connection to this family. See below for a short chart from Bernard Mattingly and Priscaill Cash. Some of this informaion is from census and marriage records and some is from another Mattingly researcher from several years ago. Bob Alvey Descendants of Bernard Mattingly (son of John Baptist and Elizabeth (Veneable?) or John Baptist Mattingly and Dykeander Boswell) I have seen it both ways. 1 Bernard Mattingly b: Abt. 1780 d: 1844 .+Priscilla Cash b: 1776 m: April 25, 1808 in Washington Co, KY d: Bef. 1860 Father: Caleb Cash Mother: Elizabeth ..2 Lucretia Mattingly b: 1812 in KY ...... +Tempton Keeling b: 1835 m: February 24, 1856 in Washington Co, KY Father: Unknown Keeling Mother: Frances Unknown ....... 3 Margaret Keeling b: 1857 in KY ..2 John Thomas Mattingly b: 1822 in KY d: 1890 ...... +Delilah M Keeling b: 1829 in KY m: November 19, 1851 in Washington Co, KY d: Abt. 1855 Father: William Keeling Mother: Ann "Nancy" Hardin ....... 3 William Lloyd Mattingly b: 1853 in KY ........... +Sylvia Baker ........... 4 John Mattingly b: 1885 ....... 3 John Barney Mattingly b: 1855 ........... +Nannie W Hobbs ..*2nd Wife of John Thomas Mattingly: ......+Elizabeth "Lizzie" Keeling b: 1837 in Washington Co, KY m: May 09, 1855 in Washington Co, KY Father: William Keeling Mother: Ann "Nancy" Hardin ....... 3 Mary Jane Mattingly b: Abt. 1856 in KY ........... +John W Baker ....... 3 George Robert Mattingly b: 1859 d: 1936 ........... +Alice Reddicks ....... *2nd Wife of George Robert Mattingly: ........... +Bertha Hall ....... 3 Susan Annie Mattingly b: 1860 ........... +John T Neale ....... 3 Thomas F Mattingly b: 1863 ........... +Lula Reddicks ....... 3 Martha Frances "Mattie" Mattingly b: 1869 ........... +Richard Hardin ....... 3 Daniel Boone Mattingly b: 1872 ........... +Sally Burkhead ....... 3 Sadie K Mattingly b: 1875 ........... +James T Yates ..2 William Caleb Mattingly b: 1825 in KY ..Wife of William Caleb Mattingly: ......+Mary Jane Hardesty b: 1831 in KY m: January 26, 1852 in Washington Co, KY ....... 3 James B Mattingly b: 1852 in KY ....... 3 Charles F Mattingly b: 1853 in KY ..2 James J Mattingly b: 1827 in KY ...... +Sevilla Ann Keeling b: 1833 in KY m: June 10, 1852 in Washington Co, KY Father: William Keeling Mother: Ann "Nancy" Hardin ..*2nd Wife of James J Mattingly: ......+Elizabeth "Betty" Kennedy m: October 18, 1855 in Washington Co, KY ....... 3 Samuel Mattingly b: 1856 in KY ....... 3 Naomi Mattingly b: 1857 ....... 3 Mary Mattingly b: 1861 in KY ........... +James A Lewis ....... 3 Elizabeth Mattingly b: 1866 in KY ....... 3 George Mattingly b: 1869 in KY ..*3rd Wife of James J Mattingly: ......+Martha Unknown m: Aft. 1870