Thomas Warren's not being the grandfather of Leonard and Edward Mattingly would also explain the curious wording of Edward's will of 1778 in which he states "I give to my Bro. Jno. Bapt M. my Water Mill with the Lands adjoing thereto being a Slipe called Mattinglys lane, & a small parcel which my father purchased from Thomas Warren...." Surely if Thomas Warren was his Grandfather then he would have addressed him as my Grandfather Thomas Warren or Grandfather Warren. Paul Mattingly Atlanta, GA