----- Original Message ----- From: "pvenable" <pvenable@netzero.net> To: <MATTINGLY-L@rootsweb.com> Sent: Sunday, July 25, 2004 6:18 PM Subject: Re: [MATTINGLY] John Baptist Mattingly off-spring > Charles Mattingly married Elizabeth C. Herbert 4-18-1848 bond by Benedict > Mattingly. > > Charles Mattingly and Catherine Elizabeth (Herbert) Mattingly are shown on > page 4 Washington Co. KY census of 1860. > > Charles Matley 39 all born KY > Catherine 33 > George 14 > Louisa 12 > Henrietta 10 > Thomas 8 > Florance 5 > Gensey 1 > > > Baptisms St. Rose Washington Co. KY shows > Mattingley-Herbert. p.3 Frances Louise Adaline; b. Dec. 31-1848 ; bap. Mar. > 24-1849 Parents: Charles Mattingly and Catherine Elizabeth Herbert. > same. p. 31. Henrietta; b. Jan. 16-1851; bap. June 15 -1851. Parents: > as above > same. p.50. Thomas Lloyd; b.Sep. 17- 1852; bap. Mar. 14- 1853. Parents: > as above > same. p. 148 Gonzales Dominic; b. Sep. 15 - 1859; bap. Apr. 10 - 1860 > parents: as above > same p. 168. Mary Josephine; b. 1866; bap. June 15 - 1866. parents: as > above. > > The will of John McPherson of Nelson Co. KY filed in Washington Co. KY Sept > 1845 lists his children as Catherine Cecil, William McPherson, Elizabeth > Mattingly, Mildred McPherson and Margaret McPherson. I suspect this is the > Elizabeth that married Charles Mattingly in 1810. This would make her an > aunt of the Elizabeth McPherson who married Benedict Mattingly > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: <CharleyMoore@cs.com> > To: <MATTINGLY-L@rootsweb.com> > Sent: Saturday, July 24, 2004 9:47 AM > Subject: Re: [MATTINGLY] John Baptist Mattingly off-spring > > > > William, etal. Benedict Mattingly appears to be passed on to another John > > Baptist. A Couple of years ago, an attempt was made to shoe-horn him into > the > > infamous John Baptist whose Will was made in 1817 Wash Co. and settled > in1835. > > > > I do not know where he is destined to land - and would not mind having him > > under John Baptist and wife Spalding - if the shoe fits. > > Aside from that, Thanks to the Washington County History Book, here is > some > > more on the family. To the authors, along with myself, we have no lead on > > where they fit in the Mattingly picture: > > > > > > MATTINGLY, CHARLES F. bc1785, m Elizabeth McPherson, > > 24 Jul 1810, WashCo and 2d m Lusudy McPherson, cous of Elizabeth, > > children by wife by former marriage took the Mattingly name. They are: > > LUCITHA; ROSELLA; Mariah and Elzy > > > > 3d m Elizabeth C. Herbert, > 1848. > > Elizabeth made Will 21 Apr 1852 proven 18 Oct1852 Wash Co. Land not to > be > > sold at death of Husband. Leaves children *land Inherited from her > father. > > > > MATTINGLY, BENEDICT. m Elizabeth McPherson, dau ofWilliam McP. > > Children PIUS DOMINIC* ; > > ALEXANDER*; ALICEANN* ‘Eliza Angel; bp 4 Feb 1840 - all at St Rose' > WilliaM > > HENRY* bp 5 Aug 1842; SARAH VICTORIA* [ELIZABETH] b17Feb1845, bp > 20Feb1845 and > > RICHARD,b 23Oct1847, > > bp 20 Mar 1848. > > > > Above data credited to Source: Patricia Staton, > > MATTINGLY, MARIAH > > WashingtonCo, Ky Bi-Cent > > > > Charley > > wmatting@cablenet-va.com writes: > > > > > I'm wondering if anyone has seen the following site? > > > www.hudson-tech.com/genealogy This site states that Barnett/Bernard > > > Mattingly, son of John Baptist Mattingly and Ann Spalding, had a son > named > > > Benedict. Barnett's wife was Priscilla Cash and that seems fairly > accurate > > > according to all I've seen. Benedict's first wife was reportedly > Elizabeth > > > McPherson and that also seems correct. > > > > > > I know the 1820 census shows Barnet with two sons under the age of 10 > and > > > the 1840 census shows him with four sons: Two between ages of 20 and > 30; > > > one aged 5 to 10; and one under age 5. It is obvious that Benedict > could > > > have been one of the boys under the age of 10 in 1820 and between the > ages > > > of 20 and 30 in 1840 as Benedict was born about 1811. Benedict's second > > > wife was Martina Downs. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ==== MATTINGLY Mailing List ==== > > <Z>WELCOME TO THE MATTINGLY GENEALOGY GROUP<Z> > > We also have the MattinglyForum-subscribe@egroups.com > > Your Host Website http://www.wvi.com/~wb > > Rootsweb Host http://resources.rootsweb.com/surnames/m/a/MATTINGLY/ > > To Unsubscribe or contact the List Owner MATTINGLY-admin@rootsweb.com > > > mailto:MATTINGLY-L-request@rootsweb.com?subject=unsubscribe&body=unsubscribe > > > mailto:MATTINGLY-D-request@rootsweb.com?subject=unsubscribe&body=unsubscribe > > > > ============================== > > Gain access to over two billion names including the new Immigration > > Collection with an Ancestry.com free trial. Click to learn more. > > http://www.ancestry.com/rd/redir.asp?targetid=4930&sourceid=1237 > > > > > > >

I've been following these reports on Charles with interest. I'm about at the conclusion that Charles was not a son of Benedict Mattingly and Elizabeth McPherson. Based on the 1840 census Benedict and Elizabeth had two sons prior to 1840; one was Alexander Sylvester and the other was Pius Dominick. I think Charles was a son of Benedict Mattingly, born about 1799, who was in turn a son of Joseph Mattingly and grandson of John Baptist who died in 1817 and a 1st cousin to the Benedict that married Elizabeth McPherson. That is the relationship if that Benedict (1811) was actually a son of Barnett/Bernard (brother to Joseph). These are my current opinions of-course and subject to change if we can find some evidence of Charles parentage or the parentage of Benedict 1811 that contradict this opinion. ********************************** > > Charles Mattingly married Elizabeth C. Herbert 4-18-1848 bond by Benedict > > Mattingly. > > > > Charles Mattingly and Catherine Elizabeth (Herbert) Mattingly are shown on > > page 4 Washington Co. KY census of 1860. > > > > Charles Matley 39 all born KY > > Catherine 33 > > George 14 > > Louisa 12 > > Henrietta 10 > > Thomas 8 > > Florance 5 > > Gensey 1 > > > > > > Baptisms St. Rose Washington Co. KY shows > > Mattingley-Herbert. p.3 Frances Louise Adaline; b. Dec. 31-1848 ; bap. > Mar. > > 24-1849 Parents: Charles Mattingly and Catherine Elizabeth Herbert. > > same. p. 31. Henrietta; b. Jan. 16-1851; bap. June 15 -1851. Parents: > > as above > > same. p.50. Thomas Lloyd; b.Sep. 17- 1852; bap. Mar. 14- 1853. > Parents: > > as above > > same. p. 148 Gonzales Dominic; b. Sep. 15 - 1859; bap. Apr. 10 - 1860 > > parents: as above > > same p. 168. Mary Josephine; b. 1866; bap. June 15 - 1866. parents: as > > above. > > > > The will of John McPherson of Nelson Co. KY filed in Washington Co. KY > Sept > > 1845 lists his children as Catherine Cecil, William McPherson, Elizabeth > > Mattingly, Mildred McPherson and Margaret McPherson. I suspect this is > the > > Elizabeth that married Charles Mattingly in 1810. This would make her an > > aunt of the Elizabeth McPherson who married Benedict Mattingly