Hi, First I think we should thank Charles for all his work for the MA CENSUS LOOKUP- you are appreciated Charles! Found in the 1870 Census living in Lynn MA (on left) Page 89 (on right) # 507 Phinney James 45 Shoemaker b NY Lovania 36 b MA George H 14 b MA Annie S 10 b MA Mary A 9 b MA William M 4 Male b MA No John listed- Hope this helps, Eileen