Jack, It was only one of the others where she appeared. Hazel died in 1838 and in the 1840 census James had the older woman age 80-90 in his census record. She had not been in his household previously. I think that was their mother and if James and Hazel were brothers, it only makes sense that the whole Newberry clan belonged together even though they began moving separately later. Families did that. I need to look at all my notes for further info. Lou Ann