Good Evening Sandy..... I must kindly thank you for your wonderful assistance with the IGI and batch numbers, I went back and did a search for other children of Robert LIDDLE & Agnes and got quite a few hits I have what could be a silly question. On the 1881 census for John LIDDELL and family it says that he was from Edinburgh, could Bo'ness possibly be considered "Edinburgh"?? Thanks for your help Claire -- Claire Turner ­ British Virgin Islands http://www.claireturner.com/thefamilytree.html Researching: BRANFILL / BRANFIELD, CHAMBERLAINE, LIDDELL, LODDY / LODEY, MACARTHY / McCARTHY, ROBERTS & TURNER EoL FHS #10880