Hi Susan Let him who is without sin cast the first stone ;-) I suspect you are far from on your own in this respect However have you considered the book is wrong ? It would certainly not be the first time a publisher had incorrect data I would first get that checked and if proved to be true I would tell those that needed to know, otherwise it just perpetuates inaccurate data Which once its out the bag is very hard to retract anyway Nivard Ovington in Cornwall (UK) On 21/02/2014 16:02, Susan Chapman wrote: > Hi > For anybody interested in Westhoughton, Brass Bands or just a good social > history read - I have just obtained a copy of David Kayes book about > Wingates Band, it is excellent and I really recommend it > > However it has caused me to have another look through all my family history > photos because I have been proudly displaying a photo of my husbands > grandfather John W Byers who was a trombonist in Wingates Band.