Hi Wendy, what about this young lady? Lancashire Birth indexes for the years: 1886 SHORT Annie J Toxteth Park Liverpool TP/298/60 Sutton is near St Helens. But Liverpool is not that far from this area. Regards Mike Morris Toronto Canada ________________________________ From: Wendy Smith via <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Sent: Thursday, February 11, 2016 1:27 PM Subject: [LAN] SHORT The grand mother’s name is Annie SHORT (possibly Annie Mary Josephine SHORT). We are unsure as to where she was born but it would be somewhere between 1886 - 1888. She marries a George GOODEY in 1909 in Ireland when he is in the army based in NI. However, by 1911 they are living in Pembroke Street, London, and on this entry she gives her birth place as Sutton, Lancashire. <snip>