This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Author: jerry876_1 Surnames: Medcalf Classification: queries Message Board URL: http://boards.rootsweb.com/localities.northam.usa.states.kentucky.counties.ohio/4020.1.1.1.1.1.2.1.1/mb.ashx Message Board Post: I'm not sure we are discussing same Hulda GARTH Because I have a Hulda Louise GARTH born 7 Mar 1848 , Ohio, Kentucky died 14 Dec 1943 Herbert, Ohio, Kentucky buried St. Thomas Cemetery, Hancock, Kentucky daughter of David P. GARTH and Sarah Ellen "Sally" Callaway. Hulda Louise GARTH married William Curtis MIDKIFF born Abt 1828 , , Indiana died Abt 1882 , Ohio, Kentucky they married 28 Mar 1867 , Ohio, Kentucky. She then remarried 15 Jun 1883 Whitesville, Daviess, Kentucky to Charles Lewis Payne born 3 Oct 1838 , Daviess, Kentucky died 3 Sep 1900 , Hancock, Kentucky Elizabeth Adaline Garth born ABT. 1824 , Henry, Kentucky married Thomas B. MIDKIFF 19 Apr 1844 , Ohio, Kentucky. Elizabeth Adaline Garth was the daughter of William GARTH and Hulda ROSS who were married 19 Dec 1814 , Jefferson, Kentucky. Elizabeth Adeline GARTH was a sister to David P. GARTH who married Sarah Ellen "Sally" Callaway Thomas B. MIDKIFF I don't know his parents. but we seem to Have Midkiff's and Medcalf's families living near each other and marrying into some of the same families although not all Midkiff were Medcalf's or were Medcalf's really MIDKIFF's, but the Census and the Ohio County, KY marriage records has them all mixed up, which makes it more difficult to sort out. This still does not explain that if Hulda GARTH married John B. Haynes in Ohio Co. Jan 14, 1846, how she would be the mother in law of James Stanislaus MEDCALF if his wife was Adaline JAMES.and his wife was born abt 1825 long before Hulda GARTH married John B. HAYNES. This would seem to indicate Hulda Garth was married Previously to ? James if Adaline James was her daughter. So I still have some details I need to understand. but thanks for helping, I did not have the Hulda Garth who married John B. Haynes was Hulda GARTH married to ? James before John B. Haynes? Important Note: The author of this message may not be subscribed to this list. If you would like to reply to them, please click on the Message Board URL link above and respond on the board.