I never really got involved in this that much. Here is what I had on Benjamin. I have him married to Malinda Coots. glo 1860 Wise Co., VA census Page 74 July 12, 1860 486-486 Joseph Reason 24 M Farmer VA 486-486 Joseph Hettie 21 F Housekeeper KY 488-488 Ingle Mary 25 F Housekeeper VA 488-488 Ingle Judah 5 F VA 488-488 Ingle Benjamin F. 2 M VA 489-489 Ingle Nathan 47 M Cooper VA 489-489 Ingle Judah 47 F Housekeeper VA 489-489 Ingle Jane 19 F Seamship VA 489-489 Ingle Henry 15 M VA 489-489 Ingle Dicy 13 F VA 489-489 Ingle Franklin 10 M KY 489-489 Ingle Ruth 8 F KY 489-489 Ingle William 3 M KY Household Record 1880 United States Census Search results | Download Previous Household Next Household Name Relation Marital Status Gender Race Age Birthplace Occupation Father's Birthplace Mother's Birthplace Benjamin F. INGLE Self M Male W 21 VA Farming VA VA Lindy INGLE Wife M Female W 22 KY Keeping House KY KY Juda INGLE Dau S Female W 3 VA VA KY Sarah INGLE Dau S Female W 2 VA VA KY Polly INGLE Mother W Female W 45 VA House Keeper VA VA Source Information: Census Place Richmond, Wise, Virginia Family History Library Film 1255394 NA Film Number T9-1394 Page Number 297D 1900 Leslie Co., KY census ~ CUTSHIN PCT ~ Series: T623 Roll: 538 Page: 45 ~ June 7, 1900 88-88 Ingle Benjaman Head WM Apr 1855 45 M23yr KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Linda Wife FW May1855 45 M23yr 11/9 KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Andrew Son WM Jan 1883 17 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Mary J. Dau WF June1885 14 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle William ?I? Son WM Mar 1888 12 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Patsy Dau WF Mar 1892 8 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Dicy Dau WF June1894 5 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Polly Dau WF May1896 4 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle James Son WM May1900 0/12 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Nathan Son WM Aug 1880 19 M1yr KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Vesty D-in-Law WF Dec 1878 21 M1yr 2/2 KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Arizona Gr.Dau WF June1897 2 S KYKYKY 88-88 Ingle Benjamin Gr.Son WM Apr 1900 2/12 S KYKYKY --- On Fri, 9/24/10, Jack Martin <jdxxm@q.com> wrote: > From: Jack Martin <jdxxm@q.com> > Subject: Re: [KYKNOTT] obits--Troublesome Creek Times, Thursday, September 16, 2010 > To: kyknott@rootsweb.com > Date: Friday, September 24, 2010, 3:40 PM > >   JB, > > Doesn't this look like Nervesta and Nathan? If so it > appears Nathan's > father is Benjamin Engle, mother Linda UNK. > > 1900 census, Cutshin Prec Mag Dist 3, Leslie, KY, 7 Jun > 1900. > HH 88/88 Benjaman Ingle age 45, wife Linda age 45, son > Andrew age 17, > daughter Mary J age 14, son William J age 12, daughters > Patsy age 8, > Dicy age 5, Polly age 4, sons James age 0 months, Nathan > age 19, > daughter in law Vesty age 21, grand daughter Arizona age 2, > grand son > Benjamin age 2 months. Benjaman and Linda married 23 years. > Linda mother > of 11 children, 9 living. Nathan and Vesty married 2 years. > Vesty mother > of 2 children, 2 living. > > Jack > > On 9/24/2010 10:30 AM, Jbfrancis6@aol.com > wrote: > > Yes Lynda, I have that.  That is what I was > basing my  statement on.  But, > > have since found an email from Betty who says that > Clay  Collins is > > stepfather and Nathan Engle is father.  Betty's > husband is son  of Benjamin Engle > > brother to Polly.  So, I must take her statement > as  fact.  JB > > > > > > In a message dated 9/23/2010 11:19:32 P.M. Eastern > Daylight Time, > > LyndaCGKyCol@aol.com > writes: > > > > JB, > > > > I had this marriage record that says Polly was > a   COLLINS. > > > > KNOTT COUNTY MARRIAGE BOOK 16 Page 49 > > > > REGISTER OF   MARRIAGE > > Full names of parties, > > Husband: Spencer Combs > > Wife:  Polly  Collins > > By Whom Married: Elijah Hale > > Place of Marriage:  Bath, County of  Knott > Kentucky. > > Date of Marriage: May 31,  1922 > > Witnesses: Melvin Amburgey  and Cassie Amburgey > > Age of  Husband  42 years;Condition, > Widowed > > Age  of Wife  20 years;  Condition, > Single > > Race: White > > Husband`s Place of  Birth: Letcher  > Co.  Residence: Spider > > Wife`s Place of Birth: Knott  > Co.   Residence: Spider > > Names of Parents of Husband: Andrew Combs and  > Nancy  Combs > > Names of Parents of Wife: Clay Collins and > Vasty   Collins > > Occupation of Husband: Farmer > > Date of License: 30 day of  May  1922 > > John Sturgill  Clerk > > By_______   D.C. > > > > RECORD OF  MARRIAGE CERTIFICATE > > I, Elijah Hale a Justice  of the Peace , or > religious  order of that name, > > do certify that on  the 31 day of May 1922, at > Bath Kentucky,  under > > authority > > of the  above license, I united in Marriage > Spencer Combs and  Polly > > Collins,  the persons named and described > therein, in the presence of > > Melvin > > Amburgey and Cassie Amburgey > > I qualified and gave bond, according  to  > law, authorizing me to celebrate > > the rites of Marriage in the  County of > Knott  State of Kentucky. > > Given under my hand, this 31 day  of May 1922 > > Elijah  Hale > > A Copy,Attest: John Sturgill   Clerk > > By___________________   D.C. > > Transcribed on January 17,  2007 by Connie > Spurlock > > > > Lynda > > > > > > From:  Jbfrancis6@aol.com<Jbfrancis6@aol.com> > >> Subject: Re: > [KYKNOTT]   obits--Troublesome Creek Times, > Thursday, > > September 16, 2010 > >>   To:  kyknott@rootsweb.com > >> Date: Thursday, September 23, 2010,  > 7:16  PM > >> Carter, I think Polly was dau of Clay > >> Collins  and  Nervesta  Hall.  > Polly > >> first married Nathan  > Engle.   Nathan is son of > >> Benjamin  Engle.  That  is what I > >>   think.  JB > >> > > Knott  County Kentucky Kinfolk http://knottkentuckykinfolk.com/ > > What I kept I  lost, What I spent I had, What I > gave I have. > > Knott County KyGenWeb > > http://98.131.135.96/knott/ > > ------------------------------- > > To  unsubscribe from the list, please send an > email to > > KYKNOTT-request@rootsweb.com > with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in  the > subject and > > the body of the  message > > > >   Knott County Kentucky Kinfolk http://knottkentuckykinfolk.com/ > > What I kept I lost, What I spent I had, What I gave I > have. > > Knott County KyGenWeb > > http://98.131.135.96/knott/ > > ------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to > KYKNOTT-request@rootsweb.com > with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the > subject and the body of the message > > > > > Knott County Kentucky Kinfolk http://knottkentuckykinfolk.com/ > What I kept I lost, What I spent I had, What I gave I > have. > Knott County KyGenWeb > http://98.131.135.96/knott/ > ------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to KYKNOTT-request@rootsweb.com > with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the > subject and the body of the message >