Hello Jessie, I am not sure we are talking about the same Peytons. Let me give you a short run down on my Peytons. They were from Casey Co. , mine is Samuel Peyton born May 10 - 1881 Casey Co. ( and all of his siblings were born in Casey Co.) , sibling of Bennett -- 1867 Seany ( Senia perhaps Cerena ) --1870 Mary L.-- 1872 Sarah J. -- 1874 Robert L. -- 1876 Chrisropher C. -- 1880 Asa ( Ace ) -- 1882 Their parents were Daniel H. 11/14/1866 , and Sarah E. Taylor 1847 . Sarah was married first to William Clay Taylor. Most of these Peytons moved to Indiana , and settled in Lawrence Co . , around the first of 1900 . Some are buried in Mitchell In. and Bloomington In. Samuel was my G Uncle. Daniel is as far back as I go , and I was not aware of any of my Peytons living in Indiana in 1830s. I have good files on these Peytons , and will share them with you if we have a tie here . Thank you for your response, Bob