Hi Terri and list! Thank you for your response! Here's what I have... ----- Original Message ----- > Which later child's birth record listed Benjamin's wife's maiden name > as Warren? Film #0216816 Bath vitals 1852- 1860 at least..... lists: 1852 birth of Ruben Robertson to Ellen McClane 1855 birth of Mary E. Robertson to Ellen Warren 1859 birth of Louisa Roberson to Penelope Warren [All 3 children are listed in the 1860 Bath census with Benj. Robinson and his wife, Nella. However, Louisa is listed as Lucinda...she is Louisa in the 1870 census.] > On the other hand, > Bath County Census - 1860: Record #230 (page 31): > Benjamin ROBINSON, 46, Ky, farmer, land=$160, estate=$200; Nella, 35; > Sarah J, 24; Angeline, 22; Catharine, 20; Martha, 18; Ruth, 17; John, 15; > Henry, 13; Maranda, 12; Ruben, 8; Isabella, 5; Lucinda, 8mo > > If Nella was really 35 in 1860, she is too young to be married in April > 1834 and to be the mother of Sarah, at least. What age did you have for > her from the 1850 census? Census records state: 1850 Bath co. Nelly age 33 1860 Bath co. Nella age 35 1870 Pendleton co. Ellen age 53 1880 Pendleton co. Ellen age 63 1900 Pendleton co. Nellie age 82 (living with my ggg grandmother, Katherine) And, last but not least, on Katherine's (1838-1929) death cert her mother is listed as Nellie Warren. Again, thank you for your help. jamie