Ruth, I found this in my Whitfield Book. Charity Whitfield married (1) Fredrick O'Daniel (2) Stephen HERRING. Children: Owen O' Daniel William O' Daniel Alexander O'Daniel m . Elizabeth Grady Elizabeth O' Daniel m. William Winkfield Benjamin HERRING Whitfield HERRINGm. 1782 Mary Croom dau of Anne Grady grand dau of Mary Whitfield Apparently-Sarah Whitfield HERRING, Charity's sister, died and then Charity and Stephen HERRING married. Could be Charity O'Daniel and Charlotte Best are two different women. Can someone help us with this dilemma????? HOPE THIS HELPS. Gayle