This is a second call for review of this lineage for vetting. The results are still pending, but as no attempt is made to connect to a known line, I purpose to mark this line as vetted next week unless there are questions or concerns about the lineage. Sue Liedtke ----- Original Message ----- From: "Herbert/Marcella Campbell" <campbell@comwares.net> To: <KINCAID@rootsweb.com> Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2008 11:41 AM Subject: [KINCAID] Fw: Vetting for Thomas M. Kincaid > > > > > > > > > Vetting: Doyle Eugene Kincaid to Thomas McDowell Kincaid > Researcher: Marcella Kincaid Campbell, sister > > DNA# 130629 > Testing in Progress. > > Participant: Doyle Eugene Kincaid b. 7 February 1938 - Harrison > Township, Clay County, IN > > Son of: Solomon Kincaid and Pearl Edna Froderman > > Proven by: > > Indiana Birth Certificate listing Doyle Eugene as son of Solomon > Kincaid and Pearl Froderman > > Personal knowledge: I knew Solomon as our father and was acknowledged > by family members as his daughter and Doyle as his son. > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Solomon Kincaid b. 4 July 1889 in Jasper Co., IL d. 8 February > 1964 in Clay Co., IN > m. 5 September 1926 to Pearl Edna Froderman > > Son of: James Edgar Kincaid and Harriet Ann Addy > > Proven by: > IL Birth Certificate for Solomon Kincaid listing James Edgar Kincaid > and Harriet Addy as his parents > > Bible Record - Personal possession of Bible ("International Series" > containing Old and New Testaments published by The John C. Winston Co.) > Information recorded in Bible as follows: J.E. Kincaid of Clay Co. IN and > Harriet A. Addy of Clay Co., IN were by me united in Matrimony according > to the ordinance of GOD and the laws of Indiana at Bowling Green on the > (5) fifth day of March in the year of our Lord 1868. Signed by George > Beamer Witnessed by: Livona Kincaid, Mary Funk and Casius Funk. > NOTE: Livonia Kincaid was a sister to J.E. Kincaid (see 1850 census > for Thomas Kincaid) and Mary Funk was a twin sister to Harriet Addy. > Casius Funk was the husband of Mary Funk > > Other records in Bible list the Marriages of the children, including > Solomon on September 5, 1926, Children's Names, including Solomon Kincaid > born on 4 July 1889 along with a twin brother who died unnamed. Deaths > listed were Harriet Kincaid April 10th, 1898 and the unnamed Infant on > August 18th, 1889. I was told that this Bible belonged to James Edgar > and Harriet Kincaid and on the death of Margaret Booker (an older sister > of Solomon) was passed down to my father, Solomon Kincaid. > > Children listed in the Bible are: > > Louie Kincaid Jan, 2nd. 1869 fe > Margaret L. Kincaid Feb. 19th, 1871 fe > William Kincaid Jan, 22nd, 1873 m > Catharine Kincaid Aug. 28th, 1875 fe > John Kincaid July 15th, 1878 m > Thomas Kincaid Mar. 14, 1881 m > Ira Kincaid Feb. 1st, 1884 m > Bertha Kincaid Sept. 23rd, 1886 fe > Solomon Kincaid July 4th, 1889 m > Infant, Kincaid July 4th, 1889 m > > Marriage Application: Application for Marriage License -- Male - > shows the following: > > Solomon Kincaid , white, born in Jasper Co., Illinois on July 4th, > 1889 and presently living at Center Point, IN working as a farmer whose > father was J. E. Kincaid and his mother was Harriet Addy. Subscribed and > sworn to before _____ McIntyre, Clerk Clay Circuit Court, on 4th day of > September 1926. Information also included on Pearl E. Froderman, spouse. > > 1880 Census for South Muddy Township, Jasper Co., Illinois > > Schedule 1, Page 18, Enumeration Dist # 164 > > Dwelling # 159, Family # 164 > > Kincaid, James E 38 M Farmer Indiana KY KY > Kincaid, Harriet A 32 wife Hskp Ohio OH > OH > Kincaid, Louie 11 dau IL > IN OH > Kincaid, Margaret 9 dau IL IN > OH > Kincaid, William 7 son IL > IN OH > Kincaid, Sarah C 4 dau IL IN > OH > Kincaid, John 2 son IL > IN OH > > 1900 Census for South Muddy Township, Jasper Co., Illinois > > Sheet 11, Line 195 > > Kincade, James Dec 1841 58 Wd IN OH OH > Farmer > Kincade, John July 1878 21 IL > Farm laborer > Kincade, Thomas Mar 1881 19 IL > Farm laborer > Kincade, Ira Feb 1884 16 IL > Farm laborer > Kincade, Bertha Sept 1886 13 IL > Kincade, Solomon July 1889 10 IL > Metcalf, Charles W Feb 1873 27 IL IL IL > Farm laborer married 6 yrs > Metcalf, Catherine Aug 1875 24 IL IN IN > > Note: Catherine Metcalf was an older sister of Solomon. Solomon > was born in 1889 so does not show on 1880 census. Sarah "Catherine" > married Charles Metcalf in Feb of 1894 and was living in the household > with her father. See above. > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > James Edgar Kincaid b. 2 December 1841 in Washington Township, Clay > Co., IN d. 12 August 1918 in Richland Co., IL > m. 5 March 1868 in Clay Co., IN Bk 2, pg 784 to Harriet Ann Addy > > > Son of: Thomas McDowell Kincaid & Martha Ann McNabb > > Proven by: > > 1840 Clay Co., IN Census > Thomas M. Kincade 1 male 20-30 1 female under 5 1 female > 20-30 > > 1850 Clay Co., IN Census > Thomas M Kincaid age 34 KY > Martha age 34 KY > Livonia age 14 IN > Samuel L age 11 IN > James Edgar age 7 IN > Mary age 5 IN > Alvin 1/2 IN > . > > 1860 Clay Co. IN Census - Washington Township Dwelling house # 398, > family number 375 > Thomas M. Kincaid age 49 farmer Kentucky > Martha A. Kincaid age 44 weaver Kentucky > Livonia Kincaid age 22 weaver Indiana > Samuel L. Kincaid age 20 farm laborer Indiana > James E. Kincaid age 18 farm laborer Indiana > Eliza Kincaid age 16 spinster Indiana > Polly Kincaid age 14 Indiana > William N Kincaid age 7 Indiana > Nancy E. Kincaid age 4 Indiana > Henry L. Kincaid age 1 Indiana > > 1870 Clay Co. IN Census - Washington Township Dwelling house #132, > family number 125 > Kinkade, Thomas 59 farming Kentucky > Kinkade, Martha A 54 keeps house Kentucky > Kinkade, Samuel 31 farm laborer Indiana > Kinkade, William 17 Indiana > Kinkade, Elizabeth 14 Indiana > Kinkade, Henry L 11 Indiana > > 1880 Clay Co. IN Census - Washington Township Dwelling house #114, > family number 114 > Kingcade, Martha 64 keeps house Kentucky > Kingcade, Samuel 40 farm hand Indiana > > Dwelling house # 115, family # 115 > Kingcade, Henry 21 farm hand Indiana > Kingcade, Alma A 21 keeps house Missouri > > 1900 Clay Co. IN Census - Washington Township Dwelling house #195, > family #195 > Huber, Frank Oct, 1849 IN PA PA head > Huber, Nancy E. Mar, 1856 IN KY KY wife > Huber, Norie A Jan, 1877 IN IN IN dau > Huber, Marthie Sep, 1878 IN IN IN dau > Huber, Moris (?) M Jun 1886 IN IN IN son (hard to > read sic Lara Melton Huber) > > Kincade, Martha Jan 1816 KY KY KY m-in-law > > > NOTE: James and Harriet Kincaid moved to Jasper Co., Illinois soon > after their marriage in 1868. > Personal knowledge - Have no personal knowledge of any of the > siblings of James E. Kincaid. The last one, Henry, died in 1949 and I had > never met him. I have snapshots of Henry Kincaid with some of his > descendants and my father, Solomon. My father acknowledged that Henry was > his uncle. > > Lara (we called him Larry) Huber in the above 1900 census and my > father, Solomon (went by Toby), were first cousins. I personally knew > Larry and his wife, Eunice, as a child because we visited them often. > (Marcella Kincaid Campbell) > > --:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > Thomas McDowell Kincaid b. 27 February 1811 in KY d. 31 October > 1875 in Washington Township, Clay Co., IN > m. 18 August 1836 in Morgan Co., IN to Martha Ann McNabb b. 18 > January 1816 in KY d. 4 June 1904 in Washington Township, Clay Co., IN > > Son of: unknown > 1840 census for Washington Township, Clay Co, Indiana shows Thomas M. > Kincade, 1 male under 5, 1 male 20-30, 1 female under 5, 1 female 20-30. > Tombstone inscriptions in Mt Zion Cemetery, Washington Township, Clay > Co., Indiana show Thomas M. Kincaid Born February 12, 1811 Died > October 31, 1875 and Martha A. Kincaid Born January 18, 1816 Died June > 4, 1904 NOTE: I have photos of these stones.( Marcella Kincaid > Campbell) (Marriage Records of Morgan County, Indiana, Book A, page 305 > (1822-1842) W.R. Stevens, Clerk and Signed by A McNabb AJ states the > following: Thomas Kincade to Martha Ann McNabb August 18, 1836 > > Thomas Kincaid entered land 4 September 1837 in Washington Township, > Clay Co., IN E 1/2 NE 1/4 Sec. 28 Township 11 North of Range 5 West > > He lived there until his death in 1875. This property was in the > family for a number of years later, because it was purchased/inherited by > the daughter, Nancy. She and her husband, John Franklin Huber lived there > for a number of years. (I have not checked land records yet on the > succession of this property.) > > NOTE: An Archibald Tousley Kincaid entered land 7 October 1837 in > Washington Township, Clay co., Indiana W 1/2 NE 1/4 Section 17 Township > 11 North of Range 5 West. Cenuse record for 1850 shows Archibald > Kincaid, age 32, b. in Ohio and wife, Sarah, age 22, b. in IN, in > Washington Township, Clay Co., IN with Margaret Bradshaw, age 64, b. PA, > Nancy Kincaid, age 34, b. KY and Nelson Kincaid, age 22 b. IN > > This property is very near the property of Thomas Kincaid and > Archibald could possibly be his brother. I have a copy of a letter > addressed to Thomas Kincaid and family, dated April the th5 1855 from > Nancy Ann Kincaid. She begins by saying "Dear brother and sister". There > is no indication of where this originated. She requests that Thomas shear > her "few sheep" and that Livonia (oldest daughter of Thomas and Martha) to > spin and weave it for her. I have a copy of another letter dated February > th18 1849 from Philip McNabb of Mooresville, Morgan Co., IN to Thomas and > Marthy Kincaid. He addressed them as "Dear and mutch respected Uncle and > Aunt". I have some McNabb information which leads me to believe that > Martha Ann McNabb was the daughter of James Edgar McNabb and Polly Coryell > who came to Morgan Co. in the mid 1830's from Montgomery Co., KY. I can > prove that this Phillip McNabb (who was a doctor) was the grandson of > James Edgar McNabb. Also, Thomas and Martha na! > > med their second son (my grandfather) James Edgar Kincaid . Their first > son was named Samuel. > > The 1860 census for Washington Township, Clay Co, IN shows Nancy L. > Kincaid, 48, weaver b. KY living with the Martin Crows (Crouse) family. > There is a 4 year discrepancy in the age of the Nancy with Archibald and > this Nancy, but still could be the same person. > > The children of Thomas McDowell Kincaid and Martha Ann McNabb were: > > 1. Livonia Kincaid b. 2 February 1837, Clay Co., IN d. 27 > November 1924, Clay Co., IN m. Michael Huber 12 December 1869 in Clay > Co., IN Bk 3, pg 31 > > 2. Samuel L. Kincaid b. 25 September 1839 in Clay Co., IN d. 16 > October 1911 in Clay Co., IN Unmarried - Served in Civil War > > 3. James Edgar Kincaid b. 2 December 1841 in Clay Co., IN d. 12 > August 1918 in Richland Co., IL > m. Harriet Ann Cain or Addy (family used both surnames) 5 March > 1868 in Clay Co., IN Bk 2 pg 784 Served in Civil War > > 4. Eliza Kincaid b. 19 November 1843 in Clay Co., IN d. 32 March > 1924 in Clay Co. (or possibly Owen Co.) IN > m. Charles P. Chambers 19 August 1860 in Clay Co., IN Bk 1, pg 522 > > 5. Mary "Polly" Kincaid b. 12 April 1846 in Clay Co., IN d. 14 > October 1927 in Niota, TN m. Abner T. Perry Ray 15 March 1864 in Clay > Co., IN Bk 2 pg 149 > > 6. Alvin M. Kincaid b. 15 February 1850 in Clay Co., IN d. 9 > October 1851 (probably in Clay Co., IN) > > 7. William Nelson Kincaid b. 15 March 1853 in Clay Co., IN d. 5 > July 1942 (probably in Cumberland Co., IL) m. > Johanna Elizabeth Staley in Clay Co., IN Bk 4 pg 83 > > 8. Nancy Elizabeth Kincaid b. 27 March 1856 in Clay Co., IN d. 24 > January 1935 in Clay Co., IN m. John Franklin Huber 26 March 1847 in > Clay Co., IN Bk 3 pg 504 > > 9. Henry Lewis Kincaid b. 16 September 1858 in Clay Co., IN d. 22 > November 1949 in Blackford Co., IN m. Alma Alice Cravens 24 April 1879 in > Owen County, IN > To see the Kincaid of all spellings DNA chart in Excel: > http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~adgedge/Research/April%202004/Kincaid%20%20DNA.xls > > > ------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to > KINCAID-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the > quotes in the subject and the body of the message