The early militia lists are rather confusing as to who is who where the Andrew Kincaids are concerned, but I believe that Andrew & Archibald served in the unit below with my John Kincaid.  Andrew was probably a ranger on the frontier.  His pay receipt in 1785 indicates active duty. Archibald also has records indicating active duty militia. 1778       Archibald Kincade, [000014] private, in Capt. James Power’s Company, 7th                 Battalion, Cumberland County, PA Militia, commanded by Col. Gibson,                 July 1778. Pennsylvania Archives, s. 2, v. 15, p. 614; s. 5, v. 6, p. 467. 1778       Archibald Kincade, [000014] private, 2nd Class, 8th Company commanded by                 Capt. James Power, 7th Battalion, Cumberland County, PA Militia served 2nd tour                 300 men to Ye Standing Stone, July 14, 1778.  Record proves active duty. Pennsylvania State Archives Online Card File. 1780       Andrew Kincaid, private, 7th Class, 8th Company, 5th Battalion Cumberland County,                 PA Militia,  Class Roll, 1780-83.   Inactive Duty Militia.  Record does not prove active                 duty.  Pennsylvania State Archives Online Card File. 1780       Archabald Kincaid, private, 2nd Class, 8th Company, 5th Battalion Cumberland County,                 PA Militia,  Class Roll, 1780-83.   Inactive Duty Militia.  Record does not prove active                 duty.  Pennsylvania State Archives Online Card File.1780       Jno. Kincaid, private, 7th Class, 8th Company, 5th Battalion Cumberland County,                 PA Militia,  Class Roll, 1780-83.  Inactive Duty Militia.  Record does not prove                 active duty.  Pennsylvania State Archives Online Card File. 1782       Archibald Kincaid, [000014] private, in 2nd Class, 8th Company, 5th Battalion,                 Cumberland County, PA Militia under Capt. John Nelson, called to duty 1782.                 Pennsylvania Archives, s. 5, v. 6, p. 365. 1782       Andrew Kincaid, [1263] private, in 7th Class, 8th Company, 5th Battalion,                 Cumberland County, PA Militia under Capt. John Nelson, called to duty 1782.                 Pennsylvania Archives, s. 5, v. 6, p. 366. 1782       John Kincaid, [4164] private, in 7th Class, 8th Company, 5th Battalion, Cumberland                 County, PA Militia under Capt. John Nelson, called to duty, 1782. Pennsylvania                 Archives, s. 5, v. 6, p. 366. 1785       Andrew Kincaid, Cumberland County, PA Militia received per certificate #6488,                 9.6.6. 19 Sept. 1785.  Record Proves Active Duty.Pennsylvania State Archives                 Online Card File. 1785       John Kincaid, [4164] Cumberland County, PA Militia received per certificate #6526,                 9 pounds on Sept. 19, 1785.  Record proves active duty. Pennsylvania State Archives                 Online Card File. 1785       George Kinkead [4164] taxed in Toboyne Township, Cumberland County, PA for                 97 acres, 1 horse, 1 cow.  Pennsylvania Archives, s. 3, v.. 20, p. 759. 1785       John Kinkead [4164] taxed in Toboyne Township, Cumberland County, PA for                 97 acres, 1 horse, 1 cow.  Pennsylvania Archives, s. 3, v. 20, p.. 759. 1785       Archibald Kinkead [000014] taxed in Tyrone Township, Cumberland County,                 PA for 250 acres, 3 horses, 2 cows.  Pennsylvania Archives, s. 3, v. 20, p.. 764. 1786       Andrew Kincaid [1263] & Archibald Kincaid, [000014] witnesses to Edward                 Elliott’s will, of Tyrone Township, Cumberland County, PA, will written January 6, 1786,                 proved February 15, 1791. 1786       Archibald Kinkead [000014] & Andrew Kinkead [1263] received a warrant to                 take up 300 acres in Tyrone Township, Cumberland County, PA, dated,                 August 30, 1786. Pennsylvania State Archives. 1789       George Kinkead [4164] taxed in Toboyne Township, Cumberland County,                 PA for 100 acres. Cumberland County Historical Society, Carlisle, PA. 1789       Archibald Kinkead [000014] taxed in Tyrone Township, Cumberland County, PA                 for 200 acres.. Cumberland County Historical Society, Carlisle, PA. 1789       Andrew Kinkead [1263] taxed in Tyrone Township, Cumberland County, PA.                 Cumberland County Historical Society, Carlisle, PA.1793       Andrew Kinkead [1263] & his wife, Martha Townsley sold their half of 300 acres in                 Tyrone Township, Cumberland County, PA for 250 pounds on October 7, 1793,                 witness Thomas Kincaid. Cumberland County Court House, Carlisle, PA, Deed                 Book Vol. 1, Book K, p. 632.1794       Archibald Kinkead [000014] patented 336 acres, Tyrone Township, Cumberland                 County, PA, date of return, March 18, 1794. Pennsylvania State Archives. 1794       Archibald Kinkead [000014] sold 200 acres in Tyrone Township, Cumberland                 County, PA to Jacob Hartman for 110 pounds, October 14, 1794. Cumberland                 County Court House, Carlisle, PA, Deed Book Vol. 1, Book P, p. 448. Sincerely Norman Kincaide