He did post last year. I am pasting his post below for convenience. Peter ----- Original Message ----- From: "Richard Kinkead" <rkinkead11@comcast.net> To: "Genealogy, KINCAID" <KINCAID@rootsweb.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2007 6:41 PM Subject: [KINCAID] Vetting Post #2562 > Richard Neil Kinkead to David Kinkead b. 1761 > ----------------------------------------------------------- > > Participant: Richard Neil Kinkead DNA #2562 Group A set 1a > ------------------------------------ > > Richard Neil Kinkead b. (25Jan1947, Chicago, Cook, Illinois) > > Son of Robert Miller Kinkead and Joan Marie Deignan > > Proven by *Illinois birth certificate naming above parents > ------------------------------------ > Robert Miller Kinkead b. (22Aug1923, Chariton, Lucas, Iowa) > > Son of George Washington Kinkead and Hildreth Marie Miller > > Proven by *Iowa birth certificate naming above parents > ------------------------------------ > George Washington Kinkead b. (16Sep1895, Whitebreast Twp., Lucas, > Iowa) > > Son of Robert L. Kinkead and Mary Ida Mitchell > > Proven by *1910 U.S. Census, Iowa, Wayne, Union Twp., District 172 > *1920 U.S. Census, Iowa, Lucas, Whitebreast, District 96 > *Iowa State Census 1925, Lucas, Lincoln Twp. > ------------------------------------ > Robert L. Kinkead (poss. but unproven middle name: Lincoln) b. > (25Feb1868, Twenty Milestand, Union Twp., Warren Co., Ohio) > > Son of Robert Willis Kinkead and Rebecca Foster Scott > > Proven by *Iowa State Census, 1885, Lucas, Whitebreast Twp. > *1870 U.S. Census, Iowa, Lucas, Whitebreast Twp. > ----------------------------------- > Robert Willis Kinkead b. (25Feb1817, Wheeling Twp., BelmontCo., Ohio) > > Son of Joseph Kinkead and Eleanor Willis > > Proven by *Estate settlement document on file Louisa Co., Iowa, naming > living children of Joseph Kinkead > *Family document dictated by RWK's sister, Mary Jane > Kinkead Campbell, to her son, naming all of Joseph Kinkead's children. > (MJKC proven by 1850 U.S. Census of Ohio, Licking, > Burlington Twp., Homer, at which time RWK had married and left the > household ) > ---------------------------------- > Joseph Kinkead b. (24Nov1793, Burlington Co., New Jersey) > > Son of David Kinkead and Mary Land > > Proven by *Will of David Kinkead, 20Aug1820, on file in Guernsey Co., OH, > naming "my sons John and Joseph." > (This is the only David Kinkead married in New Jersey [1787], > in the right place [Belmont/Guernsey Cos., OH], > at the right time, having sons John and Joseph in 1820 > isolated > in the will from his other children [of a second wife]. > *Family documents cite John Land Kinkead, b. 14Nov1789 in > Burlington, NJ, as Joseph's brother. > David's father-in-law was John Land of Burlington, NJ. Joseph > named his third son John Land Kinkead.) > ---------------------------------- > David Kinkead b. (Abt. 1761, Ireland) > > Son of (possibilities still speculative) > > * Copies in my possession > _______________________________________________________________________________________ > > Dick Kinkead 2562 > Lantana, FL ----- Original Message ----- From: "Sue Liedtke" <seleaml@actionnet.net> To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> Sent: Thursday, July 24, 2008 1:52 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] Westmoreland County, PA > Alice has posted the updated chart so as far as I know it is up to date. > > I have you listed with an unvetted earliest ancestor Joseph b 1793 m > Eleanor > Willis. I do not have a New Jersey county listed for you so don't know if > it > is possible that Joseph's father may have come from the New Castle Co. > Delaware branch from 19324 who is vetted to William/Sarah b c1700 thru his > son Joseph the clockmaker. This line has not been upgraded to 37 markers > from 25 so technically should be placed in the Group A undetermined > section > but there is strong indication that 5164 comes from this line. Elaine > believes 5164's ancestor was George William b 1792 of Cecil Co. MD who may > be the son of Alexander the clockmaker. > > To bring yourself up to par and to let all of us know where you are in > your > search, you might want to consider a vetting post. It is always best to > make > sure you are on very firm footing before continuing back. If you should > decide to do this, I would be happy to work with you as to format and > organization before you post to the list. > > Sue Liedtke > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Richard Kinkead" <rkinkead11@comcast.net> > To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> > Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2008 6:54 AM > Subject: Re: [KINCAID] Westmoreland County, PA > > >> Sue- >> >> Is the DNA chart site up to date? >> >> Norman's work in Westmoreland County is getting close to home and I need >> to >> take another look and get up to speed. I need to find where MY Mary >> Kinkead >> (d. 1795 in W. Co.) is buried, as well as a record of MY David Kinkead's >> marriage to Elizabeth McCarty/McCardy, which I believe took place there, >> too. The family only stayed there for five years before moving on to >> Belmont Co., OH, but I believe they went to W. Co. from NJ because there >> were close relatives there. Norman's discoveries and recent DNA test >> results seem to bear this out. >> >> Thanks ( for all you do ), >> >> Dick Kinkead 2562

Yes, I did post last year, twice. But there were flaws in it again, so I put it off. Now there's updated info, a broken brick wall and more detail. I'll re-do and re-post next week when I get back from Californica. Dick Kinkead 2562 Lantana, FL ----- Original Message ----- From: "Peter A. Kincaid" <7kincaids@primus.ca> To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> Sent: Thursday, July 24, 2008 3:56 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] Westmoreland County, PA > He did post last year. I am pasting his post below for > convenience. > > Peter > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Richard Kinkead" <rkinkead11@comcast.net> > To: "Genealogy, KINCAID" <KINCAID@rootsweb.com> > Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2007 6:41 PM > Subject: [KINCAID] Vetting Post #2562 > > >> Richard Neil Kinkead to David Kinkead b. 1761 >> ----------------------------------------------------------- >> >> Participant: Richard Neil Kinkead DNA #2562 Group A set 1a >> ------------------------------------ >> >> Richard Neil Kinkead b. (25Jan1947, Chicago, Cook, Illinois) >> >> Son of Robert Miller Kinkead and Joan Marie Deignan >> >> Proven by *Illinois birth certificate naming above parents >> ------------------------------------ >> Robert Miller Kinkead b. (22Aug1923, Chariton, Lucas, Iowa) >> >> Son of George Washington Kinkead and Hildreth Marie Miller >> >> Proven by *Iowa birth certificate naming above parents >> ------------------------------------ >> George Washington Kinkead b. (16Sep1895, Whitebreast Twp., Lucas, >> Iowa) >> >> Son of Robert L. Kinkead and Mary Ida Mitchell >> >> Proven by *1910 U.S. Census, Iowa, Wayne, Union Twp., District 172 >> *1920 U.S. Census, Iowa, Lucas, Whitebreast, District >> 96 >> *Iowa State Census 1925, Lucas, Lincoln Twp. >> ------------------------------------ >> Robert L. Kinkead (poss. but unproven middle name: Lincoln) b. >> (25Feb1868, Twenty Milestand, Union Twp., Warren Co., Ohio) >> >> Son of Robert Willis Kinkead and Rebecca Foster Scott >> >> Proven by *Iowa State Census, 1885, Lucas, Whitebreast Twp. >> *1870 U.S. Census, Iowa, Lucas, Whitebreast Twp. >> ----------------------------------- >> Robert Willis Kinkead b. (25Feb1817, Wheeling Twp., BelmontCo., Ohio) >> >> Son of Joseph Kinkead and Eleanor Willis >> >> Proven by *Estate settlement document on file Louisa Co., Iowa, naming >> living children of Joseph Kinkead >> *Family document dictated by RWK's sister, Mary Jane >> Kinkead Campbell, to her son, naming all of Joseph Kinkead's children. >> (MJKC proven by 1850 U.S. Census of Ohio, Licking, >> Burlington Twp., Homer, at which time RWK had married and left the >> household ) >> ---------------------------------- >> Joseph Kinkead b. (24Nov1793, Burlington Co., New Jersey) >> >> Son of David Kinkead and Mary Land >> >> Proven by *Will of David Kinkead, 20Aug1820, on file in Guernsey Co., >> OH, >> naming "my sons John and Joseph." >> (This is the only David Kinkead married in New Jersey [1787], >> in the right place [Belmont/Guernsey Cos., OH], >> at the right time, having sons John and Joseph in 1820 >> isolated >> in the will from his other children [of a second wife]. >> *Family documents cite John Land Kinkead, b. 14Nov1789 in >> Burlington, NJ, as Joseph's brother. >> David's father-in-law was John Land of Burlington, NJ. Joseph >> named his third son John Land Kinkead.) >> ---------------------------------- >> David Kinkead b. (Abt. 1761, Ireland) >> >> Son of (possibilities still speculative) >> >> * Copies in my possession >> _______________________________________________________________________________________ >> >> Dick Kinkead 2562 >> Lantana, FL >

Dick, The skeleton looks good. The flesh and your additional information just needs to be added. Giving the household details for censuses (all members with ages, birth places, and in later censuses relationship to head and parents birthplace) helps move the family back in location and time as well as allowing others to make possible connections into the family. Brief descriptions of what a document is about and brief relevant quotes from the document itself helps build the case in a manner that anyone who does not have knowledge of the family can follow. Your 1st two links with a "personal knowledge" proof if you actually knew the individuals involved is all that is needed. It would be best to have an additional document or information showing that the family in the censuses is the correct family for your line in the rest of the links. More information on George Washington (such as marriage and death dates and places) and the lines back of him would also be helpful. Currently my genealogy time is limited (huge landscaping project and needed house repairs that must be done while the weather is good) and am helping Sally with her post taking 11207 back to James/Elizabeth Church (which I hope can be finalized next week) but would be happy to look your post over before it goes to the list. It does help to have someone unfamilar with the line look the post over for clarity and completeness. Sue Liedtke ----- Original Message ----- From: "Richard Kinkead" <rkinkead11@comcast.net> To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> Sent: Thursday, July 24, 2008 1:30 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] Westmoreland County, PA > Yes, I did post last year, twice. But there were flaws in it again, so I > put it off. > Now there's updated info, a broken brick wall and more detail. > I'll re-do and re-post next week when I get back from Californica. > > Dick Kinkead 2562 > Lantana, FL > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Peter A. Kincaid" <7kincaids@primus.ca> > To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> > Sent: Thursday, July 24, 2008 3:56 PM > Subject: Re: [KINCAID] Westmoreland County, PA > > >> He did post last year. I am pasting his post below for >> convenience. >> >> Peter >> >> >> ----- Original Message ----- >> From: "Richard Kinkead" <rkinkead11@comcast.net> >> To: "Genealogy, KINCAID" <KINCAID@rootsweb.com> >> Sent: Tuesday, July 03, 2007 6:41 PM >> Subject: [KINCAID] Vetting Post #2562 >> >> >>> Richard Neil Kinkead to David Kinkead b. 1761 >>> ----------------------------------------------------------- >>> >>> Participant: Richard Neil Kinkead DNA #2562 Group A set 1a >>> ------------------------------------ >>> >>> Richard Neil Kinkead b. (25Jan1947, Chicago, Cook, Illinois) >>> >>> Son of Robert Miller Kinkead and Joan Marie Deignan >>> >>> Proven by *Illinois birth certificate naming above parents >>> ------------------------------------ >>> Robert Miller Kinkead b. (22Aug1923, Chariton, Lucas, Iowa) >>> >>> Son of George Washington Kinkead and Hildreth Marie Miller >>> >>> Proven by *Iowa birth certificate naming above parents >>> ------------------------------------ >>> George Washington Kinkead b. (16Sep1895, Whitebreast Twp., Lucas, >>> Iowa) >>> >>> Son of Robert L. Kinkead and Mary Ida Mitchell >>> >>> Proven by *1910 U.S. Census, Iowa, Wayne, Union Twp., District 172 >>> *1920 U.S. Census, Iowa, Lucas, Whitebreast, District >>> 96 >>> *Iowa State Census 1925, Lucas, Lincoln Twp. >>> ------------------------------------ >>> Robert L. Kinkead (poss. but unproven middle name: Lincoln) b. >>> (25Feb1868, Twenty Milestand, Union Twp., Warren Co., Ohio) >>> >>> Son of Robert Willis Kinkead and Rebecca Foster Scott >>> >>> Proven by *Iowa State Census, 1885, Lucas, Whitebreast Twp. >>> *1870 U.S. Census, Iowa, Lucas, Whitebreast Twp. >>> ----------------------------------- >>> Robert Willis Kinkead b. (25Feb1817, Wheeling Twp., BelmontCo., >>> Ohio) >>> >>> Son of Joseph Kinkead and Eleanor Willis >>> >>> Proven by *Estate settlement document on file Louisa Co., Iowa, naming >>> living children of Joseph Kinkead >>> *Family document dictated by RWK's sister, Mary Jane >>> Kinkead Campbell, to her son, naming all of Joseph Kinkead's children. >>> (MJKC proven by 1850 U.S. Census of Ohio, Licking, >>> Burlington Twp., Homer, at which time RWK had married and left the >>> household ) >>> ---------------------------------- >>> Joseph Kinkead b. (24Nov1793, Burlington Co., New Jersey) >>> >>> Son of David Kinkead and Mary Land >>> >>> Proven by *Will of David Kinkead, 20Aug1820, on file in Guernsey Co., >>> OH, >>> naming "my sons John and Joseph." >>> (This is the only David Kinkead married in New Jersey >>> [1787], >>> in the right place [Belmont/Guernsey Cos., OH], >>> at the right time, having sons John and Joseph in 1820 >>> isolated >>> in the will from his other children [of a second wife]. >>> *Family documents cite John Land Kinkead, b. 14Nov1789 in >>> Burlington, NJ, as Joseph's brother. >>> David's father-in-law was John Land of Burlington, NJ. >>> Joseph >>> named his third son John Land Kinkead.) >>> ---------------------------------- >>> David Kinkead b. (Abt. 1761, Ireland) >>> >>> Son of (possibilities still speculative) >>> >>> * Copies in my possession >>> _______________________________________________________________________________________ >>> >>> Dick Kinkead 2562 >>> Lantana, FL >> > > To see the Kincaid of all spellings DNA chart in Excel: > http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~adgedge/Research/April%202004/Kincaid%20%20DNA.xls > > > ------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to > KINCAID-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the > quotes in the subject and the body of the message