Nevertheless, I'm still grouped with sample 15550 on the Family Tree DNA chart along with 2519.  Plue you stated: "I think the results for sample 119921 (a reputed descendant of the Sadsbury Kincaids) elimates the likelihood that James Kincaid (m. Margaret Kuhns) of Westmoreland County, PA (represented by sample 15550) is of the Sadsbury Kincaids." If that is so why would I continue to look to the Sadsbury Township, Chester County, PA Kincaids for his paper trail?  Especially when I lose track of James Kinkead the Coroner after 1786?  I still think James W. Kinkead is from the Cumberland County, PA Kincaids.  Although, lately, I have found vague connections between the Cumberland County Kincaids and the Chester County, PA Kincaids. Also I'm having trouble accessing Alice Gedge's table so I am unable to review the updates there. I'm still looking at the warrants, deeds, and surveys in Westmoreland County after 1786 to find more definitive answers to where James Kincaid, coroner, died.  I still don't believe he is the guy who died in 1812 in Brooke County, VA, later WV.  Although it appears that he is the James Kinkead in the Board of Property Case. Sincerely Norman Kincaide ----- Original Message ---- From: Peter A. Kincaid <7kincaids@primus.ca> To: kincaid@rootsweb.com Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2008 5:58:17 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] James Kinkead, Coroner & Recorder of Westmoreland County, PA I don't see sample 15550 as being closely related to your 4164.  Sample 15550 is closer to 2519. Peter ----- Original Message ----- From: "Norman Kincaide" <norman.kincaide@yahoo.com> To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2008 8:15 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] James Kinkead,Coroner & Recorder of Westmoreland County, PA > Hempfield Township is south of Salem and southwest of Derry Township and > northwest of Mount Pleasant Township, Westmoreland County, PA where Andrew > Kincaid & John Kincaid, sons of George Kincaid reside in 1790. Andrew > being first there in 1783.. Also I am looking at where sample [15550] > falls, into Group A, where my sample 4164 falls. To see the Kincaid of all spellings DNA chart in Excel: http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~adgedge/Research/April%202004/Kincaid%20%20DNA.xls ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to KINCAID-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message

Forgive me Norman in that all I have to go on here is information in your timelines. You link people to places but I can't see how you came to this as I do not have the full information that you have. I don't see how you link James Kincaid, coroner to any other place. I am reacting to you point: "I now have enough circumstancial evidence to place them within the Sadsbury, West Caln, East Caln Townships, Chester County, PA Kincaid family cluster." I noted that the recent DNA result does not link the Sadsbury Kincaids to James Kincaid (m. Margaret Kuhns). I pointed this out because I am going on the assumption that James Kincaid (m. Margaret Kuhns) is connected to James Kincaid, the coroner. This is based on your placement of him in Hempfield township in 1773. It seems to me that since the Kuhns James and the Coroner James are both from Hempfield one would look to a relation. I understand from a previous post that Margaret's grandfather, Philip Kuhns, was Sheriff of Westmoreland County. Would one not further suspect one from the Coroner's line is of similar social status to marry one of the Sheriff's line? Given the times, I do, so I assume that the Kuhns James is of the Coroner James' line. Assumptions aside I hope this one could be figured out. I have a keen interest in Kuhn James' ancestry as I have a common ancestor with sample 15550. Best wishes! Peter ----- Original Message ----- From: "Norman Kincaide" <norman.kincaide@yahoo.com> To: <kincaid@rootsweb.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2008 9:22 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] James Kinkead,Coroner & Recorder of Westmoreland County, PA Nevertheless, I'm still grouped with sample 15550 on the Family Tree DNA chart along with 2519. Plue you stated: "I think the results for sample 119921 (a reputed descendant of the Sadsbury Kincaids) elimates the likelihood that James Kincaid (m. Margaret Kuhns) of Westmoreland County, PA (represented by sample 15550) is of the Sadsbury Kincaids." If that is so why would I continue to look to the Sadsbury Township, Chester County, PA Kincaids for his paper trail? Especially when I lose track of James Kinkead the Coroner after 1786? I still think James W. Kinkead is from the Cumberland County, PA Kincaids. Although, lately, I have found vague connections between the Cumberland County Kincaids and the Chester County, PA Kincaids. Also I'm having trouble accessing Alice Gedge's table so I am unable to review the updates there. I'm still looking at the warrants, deeds, and surveys in Westmoreland County after 1786 to find more definitive answers to where James Kincaid, coroner, died. I still don't believe he is the guy who died in 1812 in Brooke County, VA, later WV. Although it appears that he is the James Kinkead in the Board of Property Case. Sincerely Norman Kincaide