Hi, Bruce.  I couldn't find that court case in my timeline, but the other two citations are to John Kinkead, grandson of John Kinkead, Merchant of Carlisle. Sincerely Norman Kincaide ----- Original Message ---- From: "btea93059@tx.rr.com" <btea93059@tx.rr.com> To: kincaid@rootsweb.com Cc: Norman Kincaide <norman.kincaide@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, July 25, 2008 4:15:08 PM Subject: Re: [KINCAID] another John in Carlisle >I'm still not convinced that it is James Kinkead, the Coroner from Westmoreland County, PA. I still think that James Kinkead who married Margaret Kuhns was the son of John Kinkead who married Mary Lee in Carlisle, PA in: 1796 John Kincaid [15550] married Mary Lee at First Presbyterian Church, Carlisle, Cumberland County, PA         on April 27, 1796.  Cumberland County Historical Society, Carlisle, PA The above John Kincaid I believe to be the son of James Kinkead of West Pennsboro, Cumberland County, PA.  These were later the Kincaids of Dickinson Township, Cumberland County, PA.< I'M NOT UP TO SNUFF ON THIS SINCE MY CONNECTION TO JOHN THE SHOPKEEPER OF CARLISLE APPEARS TO BE A FORLORN HOPE, BUT THIS JOHN IS OF THE AGE ALSO TO BE THE SHOPKEEPER'S GRANDSON THROUGH ANDREW. SO I LOOKED BACK AT MY RECORDS AND FOUND REFERENCE TO "DEBORAH" AS HIS WIFE, AND THEN FOUND THIS: #206..26 Feb 1800 Deborah Kinkead vs John Kinkead, John Kinkead prosecuted THIS IS ODD SINCE THEN I FOUND THIS: John & Deborah Kincade, Jane, Susannah & Francis Kelly, January 20, 1816 in Robert Clark's District, 1st Presbyterian Church. Church Register Pew Holders 1795-1796 SO NORM I'M CURIOUS IF YOU KNOW WHAT THIS COURT CASE WAS ABOUT THAT SEEMS TO BE WIFE VS HUSBAND -- OR MAYBE A DIFFERENT JOHN?? Bruce