Vetting Ronald L. Kincaid to George Washington Kincaid (Original Vetted by Leslie M. Revised and expanded post by Bob Arnott as original not available to Kincaid list.) DNA #49289 Group/set 2a Participant: Ronal(d) L. Kincaid Researcher: Bob Arnett (nephew of participant) Son of Willie H. Kincaid & Minnie Florence Caldwell Kincaid Proven by: Index and Register of Births- Roane County, W. Va. Page 62-7 for Ronald L. Kincaid Date of Birth August 27, 1927 parents given as Wm H. Kincaid age 37 oil worker and Minnie F. Caldwell age 37 1930 Census for Roane County West Virginia Spencer Magisterial District Spencer Corporation Sheet 8A Household 215- William H. Kincaid (head) 40 yrs. Minnie F. (wife)40 yrs. Hubert (brother)21 yrs. Hobert (brother)19 yrs. Macel (sister and mother of Researcher)18 yrs. Hiram (brother)14 yrs. Bernada (sister)11 yrs. Imogene (sister)7 yrs. Pearl (sister)6 yrs. Donal (brother)4 yrs. Ronal (participant, 2 ½ yrs.) Anna (sister)1 yr. Participant knew his mother and older siblings who acknowledged him as her child by Willie H. Kincaid. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Willie Homer Kincaid b. August 30, 1889 Roane Co. WVA d. August 4, 1930 Staats Hospital, Kanawha Co. WVA m. September 3, 1906 to Minnie Florence Caldwell son of George William Kincaid & Lula Burke Kincaid Proven by: West Virginia State Department of Health Certificate of Death 18274 for Willie Homer Kincaid. Residence Spencer (Roane Co.) WVA Date of birth Aug 30, 1889, oil field labour, wife Florence Caldwell, father Wm Kincaid born WVA, mother Lulla Burke b WVA 1920 Census for Roane County West Virginia Smithfield Magisterial District (Part) Sheet 9A, Dwelling/Family 162 Willie H. Kincaid, 30 yrs. Florence M. (wife) 29 yrs. Hubert (son) 11 yrs. Hobert (son) 9 yrs. Lula M. (daughter) 8 yrs. Hiram (son) 3 yrs. Molissa(sic) (daughter) 1 yr. 1910 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Sheet 13A, Dwelling 199/Family 203 Willie H. Kincaid 20 yrs. Minnie F. (wife)20 yrs. Hubert B. (son) 1 7/12 yrs. 1900 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Sheet 5 Dwelling/Family 82 William Kincaid 50 yrs. Louisa J. (wife) 42 yrs. Robert C. (son) 14 yrs. Stella G. (daughter) 12 yrs. Willie H. (son) 10 yrs. Pearl S. (daughter) 6 yrs. (Note: all but Pearl were personally known by Researcher in his youth) ----------------------------------------------------------------------- George William Kincaid b. January 5, 1850 Fayette Co. VA d. September 19, 1906 Roane Co. WVA m. February 16, 1878 Roane Co. WVA Lula J. Burke son of George Washington Kincaid & Mary Catherine Campbell Proven by: Register of Marriages Roane County, W. Va. 1878 line 15 for George W Kincaid age 26 b Fayette Co. and Lulu Burke age 19 b Roane Co. Parents of groom given as G.W. and Mary C. Kincaid 1890 Census Roane Co. WVA- Non-existent 1880 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Page 9, Dwelling/Family 69 George W. Kincaide (sic) 62 yrs. Mary K. (wife) 54 yrs. Francis E. (daughter) 15 yrs. __________ (son) 7 yrs. Rufus (son) 29 yrs. + three unrelated residents (Note: Daniel E. Campbell (83 yrs.) remains adjacent at Dwelling/Family 70 with in addition to himself, his wife Catherine D. (81 yrs.) and granddaughter Sarah (16 yrs.)) 1880 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Page 9, Dwelling/Family 72 Wm. G. Kincaide(sic) 28 yrs. Louisa J. (wife)22 yrs. Albert H. (son) 1 yr. (stricken with died annotation) 1870 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield Township, Page 16, Dwelling 103/Family 113 G. W. Kincaid 53 yrs. Mary C. (wife) 45 yrs. Daniel T. (son) 20 yrs. George W. (son) 16 yrs. Virginia M. (daughter) 15 yrs. Rufus A. (son) 14 yrs. Sarah M. (daughter) 12 yrs. 1860 Census for Roane County West Virginia page 111(?), Dwelling and Family number 459 Geo. W. Kincaid (head)42 yrs. Mary C. Kincaid (wife) 32 yrs. Daniel T. (son) 11 yrs. George W. (son) 10 yrs. Virginia (daughter)7 yrs. Rufus A. (son)5 yrs. Samuel W. (son)3 yrs. Sarah M. (daughter)1 yr. (Note: once again Daniel E. Campbell (63 yrs.)family is adjacent family 460 and appears to have followed George W. from Fayette to Roane County. Included in this household are- Catherine, 65 yrs., Sarah R., 15 yrs., Isabell,10 yrs. And Elizabeth F., 6 yrs.) Birth and Death Dates from Tombstone in Pem Lowe Cemetery Roane County W. Va. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- George Washington Kincaid b. April 18, 1818 d. February 18, 1898 m. December 9, 1845 to Mary Catherine Campbell 1850 Census Fayette County West Virginia 14th. District page 334(?) Dwelling/Household 53 George Kincaid 33 yrs. (farmer) Mary C. (wife) 24 yrs. Mary C. Jr. (daughter)3 yrs. Danl Thos (son)1 yr. Household 52 Daniel E. Campbell, 53 yrs. (father-in-law of George W. Kincaid) Catherine, 49 yrs. Francis M., 15 yrs. Augustus V., 13 yrs. C. A., 10 yrs. Sarah R.,5 yrs.) Fayette County Marriage Register page 38 George Kincaid to Catharine Campbell December 9th, 1845 by Rev Bibb Birth and Death Dates from tombstone Roane County, W. Va Possibly son of Thomas Kincaid & Polly Davis as stated in the History of Roane County West Virginia 1774-1927 by William H. Bishop, esq., Spencer, WV, 1927, 711 pages. This document states on page 573- “George Washington Kincaid and his wife, Cathrin (Campbell, daughter of Daniel Campbell), who were married in Fayette County, Western Virginia, with their three first born children, came to Roane County in the year 1856…” Bob Arnott 5301 Preserve Parkway North Greenwood Village, CO 80121 (303) 741-3468 bobarnott@qwest.net

This is an important vetting post. Though Bob has been vetted by Leslie back to George Washington, we both feel it is prudent to make his lineage available to the list. We have test results from 135736 who also believes descent from the same George Washington. 135736 does not have the major divisional difference at marker 15 (DYS459b) that Bob has. All other test results from Fayette Co. WVA Kincaids are Group A-1. Bob's results are the only A-2 results from the area. There is reason to believe that George Washington was an integral part of the Fayette family and not an isolated new arrival. If 135736 can also be vetted back to George Washington, I intend to declare Bob's mutation as isolated downline from their first common ancestor. I do want to make sure there are no questions or reservations about either lineage before I do this. Sue Liedtke ----- Original Message ----- From: "Bob Arnott" <bobarnott@qwest.net> To: <KINCAID-L@rootsweb.com> Sent: Friday, March 06, 2009 7:37 PM Subject: [KINCAID] Vetting #49289 to George W. Kincaid (Roane County) Vetting Ronald L. Kincaid to George Washington Kincaid (Original Vetted by Leslie M. Revised and expanded post by Bob Arnott as original not available to Kincaid list.) DNA #49289 Group/set 2a Participant: Ronal(d) L. Kincaid Researcher: Bob Arnett (nephew of participant) Son of Willie H. Kincaid & Minnie Florence Caldwell Kincaid Proven by: Index and Register of Births- Roane County, W. Va. Page 62-7 for Ronald L. Kincaid Date of Birth August 27, 1927 parents given as Wm H. Kincaid age 37 oil worker and Minnie F. Caldwell age 37 1930 Census for Roane County West Virginia Spencer Magisterial District Spencer Corporation Sheet 8A Household 215- William H. Kincaid (head) 40 yrs. Minnie F. (wife)40 yrs. Hubert (brother)21 yrs. Hobert (brother)19 yrs. Macel (sister and mother of Researcher)18 yrs. Hiram (brother)14 yrs. Bernada (sister)11 yrs. Imogene (sister)7 yrs. Pearl (sister)6 yrs. Donal (brother)4 yrs. Ronal (participant, 2 ½ yrs.) Anna (sister)1 yr. Participant knew his mother and older siblings who acknowledged him as her child by Willie H. Kincaid. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Willie Homer Kincaid b. August 30, 1889 Roane Co. WVA d. August 4, 1930 Staats Hospital, Kanawha Co. WVA m. September 3, 1906 to Minnie Florence Caldwell son of George William Kincaid & Lula Burke Kincaid Proven by: West Virginia State Department of Health Certificate of Death 18274 for Willie Homer Kincaid. Residence Spencer (Roane Co.) WVA Date of birth Aug 30, 1889, oil field labour, wife Florence Caldwell, father Wm Kincaid born WVA, mother Lulla Burke b WVA 1920 Census for Roane County West Virginia Smithfield Magisterial District (Part) Sheet 9A, Dwelling/Family 162 Willie H. Kincaid, 30 yrs. Florence M. (wife) 29 yrs. Hubert (son) 11 yrs. Hobert (son) 9 yrs. Lula M. (daughter) 8 yrs. Hiram (son) 3 yrs. Molissa(sic) (daughter) 1 yr. 1910 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Sheet 13A, Dwelling 199/Family 203 Willie H. Kincaid 20 yrs. Minnie F. (wife)20 yrs. Hubert B. (son) 1 7/12 yrs. 1900 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Sheet 5 Dwelling/Family 82 William Kincaid 50 yrs. Louisa J. (wife) 42 yrs. Robert C. (son) 14 yrs. Stella G. (daughter) 12 yrs. Willie H. (son) 10 yrs. Pearl S. (daughter) 6 yrs. (Note: all but Pearl were personally known by Researcher in his youth) ----------------------------------------------------------------------- George William Kincaid b. January 5, 1850 Fayette Co. VA d. September 19, 1906 Roane Co. WVA m. February 16, 1878 Roane Co. WVA Lula J. Burke son of George Washington Kincaid & Mary Catherine Campbell Proven by: Register of Marriages Roane County, W. Va. 1878 line 15 for George W Kincaid age 26 b Fayette Co. and Lulu Burke age 19 b Roane Co. Parents of groom given as G.W. and Mary C. Kincaid 1890 Census Roane Co. WVA- Non-existent 1880 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Page 9, Dwelling/Family 69 George W. Kincaide (sic) 62 yrs. Mary K. (wife) 54 yrs. Francis E. (daughter) 15 yrs. __________ (son) 7 yrs. Rufus (son) 29 yrs. + three unrelated residents (Note: Daniel E. Campbell (83 yrs.) remains adjacent at Dwelling/Family 70 with in addition to himself, his wife Catherine D. (81 yrs.) and granddaughter Sarah (16 yrs.)) 1880 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield District Page 9, Dwelling/Family 72 Wm. G. Kincaide(sic) 28 yrs. Louisa J. (wife)22 yrs. Albert H. (son) 1 yr. (stricken with died annotation) 1870 Census Roane County West Virginia Smithfield Township, Page 16, Dwelling 103/Family 113 G. W. Kincaid 53 yrs. Mary C. (wife) 45 yrs. Daniel T. (son) 20 yrs. George W. (son) 16 yrs. Virginia M. (daughter) 15 yrs. Rufus A. (son) 14 yrs. Sarah M. (daughter) 12 yrs. 1860 Census for Roane County West Virginia page 111(?), Dwelling and Family number 459 Geo. W. Kincaid (head)42 yrs. Mary C. Kincaid (wife) 32 yrs. Daniel T. (son) 11 yrs. George W. (son) 10 yrs. Virginia (daughter)7 yrs. Rufus A. (son)5 yrs. Samuel W. (son)3 yrs. Sarah M. (daughter)1 yr. (Note: once again Daniel E. Campbell (63 yrs.)family is adjacent family 460 and appears to have followed George W. from Fayette to Roane County. Included in this household are- Catherine, 65 yrs., Sarah R., 15 yrs., Isabell,10 yrs. And Elizabeth F., 6 yrs.) Birth and Death Dates from Tombstone in Pem Lowe Cemetery Roane County W. Va. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- George Washington Kincaid b. April 18, 1818 d. February 18, 1898 m. December 9, 1845 to Mary Catherine Campbell 1850 Census Fayette County West Virginia 14th. District page 334(?) Dwelling/Household 53 George Kincaid 33 yrs. (farmer) Mary C. (wife) 24 yrs. Mary C. Jr. (daughter)3 yrs. Danl Thos (son)1 yr. Household 52 Daniel E. Campbell, 53 yrs. (father-in-law of George W. Kincaid) Catherine, 49 yrs. Francis M., 15 yrs. Augustus V., 13 yrs. C. A., 10 yrs. Sarah R.,5 yrs.) Fayette County Marriage Register page 38 George Kincaid to Catharine Campbell December 9th, 1845 by Rev Bibb Birth and Death Dates from tombstone Roane County, W. Va Possibly son of Thomas Kincaid & Polly Davis as stated in the History of Roane County West Virginia 1774-1927 by William H. Bishop, esq., Spencer, WV, 1927, 711 pages. This document states on page 573- "George Washington Kincaid and his wife, Cathrin (Campbell, daughter of Daniel Campbell), who were married in Fayette County, Western Virginia, with their three first born children, came to Roane County in the year 1856." Bob Arnott 5301 Preserve Parkway North Greenwood Village, CO 80121 (303) 741-3468 bobarnott@qwest.net To see the Kincaid of all spellings DNA chart in Excel: http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~adgedge/Research/April%202004/Kincaid%20%20DNA.xls-------------------------------To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email toKINCAID-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotesin the subject and the body of the message