Cindy Kimes wrote: > > This one caught my attention... a bio at > http://www.heritagepursuit.com/Fulton/FultonBio368.htm > says Sarah was the daughter of Henry Kime. > > Anyone working on this line? Which is correct? > > Name : Sarah Kump > Birth date : 11 Apr 1832 > Father name : Samuel Kime > Mother name : Esther Beaver > I'm not working directly on this line; I'm researching the other Kimes family in Mahoning, but here is what I have for this Kime family: Note: Mahoning county, Ohio was formed in 1846 from Trumbull and Columbiana counties 1- Trumbull County, Ohio Marriages has: Garret W Barom m.Esther Kime 10-10-1839 Henry Kime m.Betsey Hoyles 11-29-1838 2- The 1840 Census of Trumbull county, Ohio has: Henry Kime, 1 male 20-30; 1 f 5-10; 1 f 20-30 Saml Kime*, 1 m 15-20; 1 m 50-60; 2 f 5-10; 1 f 15-20; 1 f40-50 Garrett H Baum, 1 m 20-30, 1 f 20-30 *ancestry.com has this as 'Kinnie' 3- From 'Biographical Sketches of Williams County, Ohio': "Mr. Baum [Garrett H Baum] was married, Oct 10, 1839 to Esther Kime, who was born in Dauphin County, Penn., February 20, 1817, and was the daughter of Samuel and Esther (Beaver) Kime." 4- An on-line posting states: "In the Probate Records of Trumbull Co. in Vol 12, p. 103, dated 1843 is a listing of the inventory of the estate of Samuel Kime and mentions the widow is Esther Kime". 5- An on-line posting states that there is 2nd Kime estate/probate in Trumbull County, Ohio: Henry Kime, d.1843 6- The 1850 Census of Milton township, Mahoning county, Ohio has: Ester Kime (60, b/PA), Sarah (18), Catherine (11), George W (6). Next door is: Enoch Kime (25), Eliza (22), Malvina (1) 7- Sarah Kime married Levi Kunp [Kump] 17 May 1855 Mahoning County, Ohio 8- In the 1860 Census of Fulton Co, Ohio is: Garret H Baum (43), Ester (43), Sylvester (19), Angeline (15), Lorinda (11), Ester C (9), Curtis H (6), Catherine Jones (80), Rachel S (60). Next door is: Levi Kump (28), Sarah (30), Reuben (4), Ada (2), Oliver (4/12s) Based on the above: a- As Ester Kime is age 60 in 1850, she is probably too old to be the mother of Catherine (born when Ester was ~49), and George W (born when Ester was ~54). Ester could be the mother of Sarah (born when Ester was ~42). b- Henry Kime, born 1810-1820, doesn't appear in the 1850 Census in Mahoning. This is probably the Henry Kime who died c1843 in Trumbull county, Ohio. c- Henry Kime is of the right age to be a son of Samuel & Ester Kime. If so, it would be reasonable to assume that, if he and his wife died before 1850, his children might be raised by his parents. d- Catherine, in the household of Ester Kime in 1850, is age 11. She should be in the 1840 Census - but she doesn't appear to be in the household of Samuel Kime, Henry Kime, or Garrett Baum. Is her 1850 Census age incorrect or did the 1840 Census taker mis-record her age? Eg., should the female age 5-10 in the household of Henry Kime actually be age 0-5? e- Given that Henry Kime married in 1838, it is unlikely that he is the father of Sarah, born 1832. I *think* the correct family outline is something like this: 1. Samuel Kime b.1790 d.1843 Trumbull County, Ohio ..+Esther/Ester Beaver b.c1790 Pennsylvania d.after1850 ...2. Henry Kime b.c1815 d.1843 Trumbull County, Ohio .....+Betsey Hoyles b.c1815 d.before1850 m.1838 ......3. Catherine Kime b.c1839 d.? ; living w/grandparents in 1850 Census ......3. George W Kime b.c1843 d.? ; living w/grandparents in 1850 Census ...2. Esther Kime b.1817 Pennsylvania m.1839 Trumbull county, Ohio .....+Garrett Baum b.c1817 ...2. -dau- Kime b.1820-1825 (= female aged 15-20 in 1840 Census) ...2. Enoch Kime b.c1824 .....+Eliza ? b.c1827 ...2. -dau- Kime b.1830-1835 (= female aged 5-10 in 1840 Census) ...2. Sarah Kime b.1832 .....+Levi Kump Sorry for the extra long post! --- Karen Arp karp@pobox.com