HI KAY THE LIST OF WHITTLY`S YOU SENT ME HAD THREE OF THE PEOPLE I WAS LOOKING FOR BUT THREE ARE STILL MISSING THEY ARE WILLIAM BENJAMIN WHITTLY THE FATHER BENJAMIN WHITTLY AND DAUGHTER ROSE BEATRICE VICTORIA ( HER LAST NAME IS SPELT WHITELY . THE TWO CHILDREN BETWEEN 1883 AND 1890 THE FATHER WOULD BE AROUND 1860 IF HE WAS BORN IN THIS COUNTRY KIND REGARDS BILL