I have much on Hugh Vesty Byrne and Sarah Dwyer. I know that Sylverster Byrne and Rosanna ms Byrne were Hugh's parents. I have a problem with some info I have received. The info from one direction gives Charles Byrne (with a possible Mary as wife) as the parents of Sylvester Byrne. I was all excited as I and others had been tracking back for years trying for this information. Then: blow me down, another source, usually reliable from a chap in NSW, that the Charles at least is the name of Rosanna's father. Would anyone have any clue as to which is correct. Maybe with the long arm of coincidences they BOTH have fathers named Charles. These Byrne families set my teeth on edge sometimes. Be grateful to have Charles attached to the correct family. Too easy to say OK this must be right and stick it where it should not be in frustration. regards Paddy NSW Australia