Hmmm! Interesting - if Isabella's son in law (John Donaldson) was a groom working for the Cardens. I guess I'll have to look through every one of the 364 pages of the book written by Arthur Carden to see if there's a picture of him in there. So far, I did find that a SAMUEL Donaldson had a home there, three people living in it (page 333), not sure what year that was. It's fun to find something new to do some research on! Thanks to everyone for their input. Heidi