Kathleen, I will surf for you. Is Kilcoleman KERRY or Limerick? Ellen was b ~ 1851-58. Looking at the 1910 census in Chicago, there looks to be only ONE? possibility. The other 2 candidates in 1910 are too young? Nellie Butler, b 1886, Bridget b. 1875 -- both in IRE. Chicago Ward 5, Cook Co, IL William Butler, 44, IRE Mary, 44 (1866), IRE, arrived 1887 Jennie 23, IL (all kids IL) Mae, 18 Wm 16 Cassie 15 Pierce 12 Helen 8 Joe 6 Margery 11 mos.