I thought it would be interesting to share what records we on the list have and which ones have a corresponding civil record. This is what I have regarding family marriages in Manhattan between 1872-1929: 1872 marriage certificate and liber book registration from Health Department stating marriage took place at St. Michael 1878 marriage certificate from Immaculate Conception; there is no Health Department record of this event 1881 marriage certificate from Holy Cross; there is no Health Department record of this event c. 1881 marriage on west side where there is no Health Department record of the marriage 1882 marriage certificate from Immaculate Conception; there is no Health Department record of this event c. 1885 marriage on west side where there is no Health Department record of the marriage c. 1890 marriage on west side where there is no Health Department record of the marriage 1892 marriage certificate from St. Gabriel; there is no Health Department record of this event c.1898 marriage on east side where there is no Health Department record of the marriage c. 1900 marriage on west side where there is no Health Department record of the marriage 1902 marriage certificate from Health Department stating marriage took place at St. Augustine in the Bronx 1903 marriage certificate from Holy Cross; there is no Health Department record of this event 1905 marriage certificate from Health Department stating marriage took place at Epiphany 1919 marriage certificate from Ascension and City Clerk marriage license; NO Health Department record 1920 marriage certificate from Ascension and City Clerk marriage license; NO Health Department record 1929 marriage certificate from Ascension, City Clerk marriage license AND a Health Department certificate