My two cents worth: from Shelby Co., KY to Putnam Co., IN 1825--John and Nancy O'Neal and family. Settled in Greencastle Twp. from Montgomery Co., KY to Putnam Co., IN 1827--Elijah Jenkins with son John M. Jenkins. Settled in Warren Twp. just north of Putnamville. from Montgomery Co., KY (Mt. Sterling) to Putnam Co., IN in 1820s--Permelia Wood. Married James O'Neal, son of John (above) in 1840. John O'Neal