Lisa; I believe I have the answer to your question about the grave on the Fillmore road. I found this info. in the County Health office one time I was digging around there. The health office had lists of cemeteries in the county and I made copies of most of them. The one you are asking about was called the "Nathaniel Cunningham Grave", located at the NW1/4 SE1/4 section 13-14-4. Approximately 3 1/2 miles east of Greencastle in Greencastle Twp. In addition th Nathaniel's name this listing says the following " N. - VA Regiment Revolutionary War. Government Stone This is the only grave evident at this location.The Heirs of Nathaniel Cunningham is listed complete record book B in the Putnam County Clerk's office were as follows: Elizabeth Cunningham - Widow Alexander Cunningham Amelia Cunningham Daniel Butler Sally Butler - Wife of Daniel Jeremiah Stiles Susannah Stiles -Wife of Jeremiah Absalom Brown Elizabeth Brown -Wife of Absalom William Bailey Lucinda Bailey - Wife of William John W. Cunningham Benjamin Cunningham This same reference states that Nathaniel died in 1827." Now aren't you sorry you asked. For some reason I want to believe that this grave was moved to Forest Hill Cemetery but I can not find the source for that information right now.