Robert isn't mentioned in the entry for Isaiah & Sarah, but there is a Robert listed on pgs. 22, 25, 26, 34, 46, 77. On pg. 22... "Probably the second grist-mill in the county that was operated by water-power was situated on Indian Creek, a short distance above the place where Craig's Mill now stands on that stream. This was in operation as early as 1818, and was owned by Robert Dougherty, who in a year or so sold to a man named Bowers." On pg. 25... Under the heading of Shawswick Township... "...The appreciation of the early settlers for this land in Shawswick Township will be seen by comparing the following list of land entries with those made in some other portion of the county of about equal area, as, for instance, Pleasant Run Township, covering the same period of time:...William Dougherty, 1817;...Samuel Dougherty, 1817;...Robert Dougherty, 1817;..." On pg. 26... I didn't find him on this page...only a mention of Dougherty's Ferry. On pg. 34... Under the heading of The County Paupers... "...In 1820 Robert Dougherty was paid $41.11 for care of one Ritter, a pauper." On pg. 46... Under the heading of "Unable to Agree"... "In a case between Robert Dougherty and James Glover, appealed from a Justice Court, we find the jury discharged because they were unable to agree. This is the first case of the kind in the county, and there was probably very little at stake between the parties..." On pg. 77... Under the heading of "Bedford Methodist Episcopal Church" "In 1826 a little band of about forty Methodists was organized into a regular church called the Methodist Episcopal Church of Bedford. Among the first members appear the familiar and respected names of...Robert Dougherty, wife, son and daughter,..." If you think this is your Robert, I would be more than happy to photocopy the pages and send them to you. LIZ