In the Garaghty house in Herrin in 1910, the last name of Eva D. could be Belck or Belch. I still think it is probably Belcher. Eva married Gustave Smith, so he would be the father of the Smith children. I believe Eva was a Hutton, daughter of Eliza's first husband, A. J. Hutton. They were married in Alexander Co. IL. In 1880 census: 1880 Census - Clear Creek - Alexander Co Illinois - p. 140D - #141/141 - e numerated June 26, 1880 A. J. HUTTON - self, married, male, white, age 28, born in Tennessee, Bo ok Agent, father born in Alabama, mother born in Tennessee Eliza Hutton - wife, married, female, white, age 19, born in Illinois, Kee ping House, father born in Illinois, mother born in Tennessee Evvie Hutton - daughter, single, female, white, age 2, born in Illinois, f ather born in Tennessee, mother born in Illinois W. H. Gale - other, widower, white, male, age 35, born in Missouri, labore r, father born in VA, mother born in VA H. Goodman - other,widower, white, male, age 28, born in Illinois, labore r, father born in Tennessee, mother born in Tennessee They were in Jackson Co. in 1900: 1900 Census - Makanda Township - Jackson Co Illinois - p. 177 - #29/30 - E numeration Date - June 2, 1900 GARAGHTY, EDMOND - head, white, male, born Feb. 1842, age 58, married 17yr s, born in Missouri, father born in Illinois, mother born in Ohio, boardi ng house Garaghty Lliza - wife, white, female, born July 1860, age 39, married 17yr s, 4 children born - 3 living, born in Illinois, father born in Illinoi s, mother born in Tennessee Garaghty, Emil E. - son, white, male, born Aug 1880, age 14, single, bo rn in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois, day labo rer Smith, Eva - daughter, white, female, born April 1878, age 22, marri ed - 5 yrs., 4 children born - 2 living, born in Illinois, father bo rn in Illinois, mother born in Illinois Garaghty, Zula - daughter, white, female, born March 1888, age 12, singl e, born in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois Garaghty, Laura - daughter, white, female, born April 1877, age 23, singl e, born in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois Garaghty, Allace - daughter, white, female, born Oct 1880, age 19, singl e, born in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois Garaghty, Irtus - grandson, white, male, born Jan. 1892, age 8, single, bo rn in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois, at schoo l Smith, Ursie - granddaughter, white, female, born Sept 1896, age 3, singl e, born in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois Smith, Mary - granddaughter, white, female, born Apr. 1899, age 1, singl e, born in Illinois, father born in Illinois, mother born in Illinois Robbs, Catherine - boarder, white, female, born May 1829, age 71, widowe d, married 41 yrs, 8 children - 4 living, born in Illinois, father bo rn in Illinois, mother born in Illinois If anyone recognizes any of the name in this family, please let me know. I have a picture of an Eva Nelson. I'm wondering if this could be Eva Smith or Eva Belcher.................