Norm, I was right that this is the same line, but we skipped a generation. John R. COFFEE and Nancy RHINE had a son named William , b. 1870. William married Josephine Unknown and one of their children was James Arthur COFFEE. Then we can go from there forward. Most of these people are buried at Rhine Cemetery. I apologize for the mistake. But this is now a more definite connection, because the RHINE side is one of my major lines (and my maiden name as well). If you would like more, let me know. Best wishes, Barbara