Jon, I am related to Kyle Onstott through his grandmother, Ann Wells, who was a sister to my ggg-grandmother, Jane Wells. According to the information I have, Ann Wells married Elihu Onstott on 30 Jan 1840 in Perry Co., IL. Ann was born 15 Feb 1822 in Illinois. Elihu was born 21 Mar 1816 in Indiana. They had several children. One of them was Donald Morrison Onstott, who was born 11 Mar 1850 in Perry Co., IL. He married Barbara Pyle, (who was born about 1847), on 5 Apr 1877 in Madison Co., IL . As you found previously, Barbara was first married to Andrew Pyle on 16 Mar 1864 in Perry Co., IL. Donald and Barbara were the parents of Kyle Onstott. I hope this information helps, and have more on Elihu Onstott if you're interested. Cheryl Luginbill (researching Gill, Taylor, Wells & related families in Perry Co.)